Identity Politics Exploits Decency and Compassion
This is a simple, yet profound, insight:
“Identity politics wins not by making compelling arguments, but by exploiting the inherent decency of the American people.”*
I think too often people on the Right diagnose the success of identity politics by virtue of negative factors, like venality, cowardice, self-interest, perverse incentives.
I think these negative factors can be identified in individuals, and even in some institutions, on a case-by-case basis. But I don’t think they work as universal or generalised diagnostics.
Modern Morality
The average punter, in my view and my experience, plays along with the agenda (more often dictates) of identity politics out of a genuine desire to do the right thing, treat people well and be a good citizen.
I have also found that if one takes the time to critique identity policies with this average (good-willed) punter, one can pretty easily change their mind.
(I don’t bother with activists. They are a waste of time. The battle will be won or lost in the majority non-ideologically aligned middle).
*Source: Jonah Goldberg, Suicide of the West.
___
Originally published on Dr Jonathan Cole’s page.
Subscribe to his podcast, The Political Animals, for more insights.
Photo by Gotta Be Worth It.
Recent Articles:
28 August 2026
1.4 MINS
When floods hit Nepal, killing dozens and leaving Australians missing, the Greens found their villain: Australian coal. A look at climate politics' newest ritual — the search for a sinner.
28 August 2026
3.5 MINS
Alice Springs' Greens-backed mayor had her car stolen — then refused to press charges. James Macpherson asks why the progressive answer to rising crime is to fix the narrative instead of the crime.
28 August 2026
2.8 MINS
A veteran Seattle Times sports columnist resigned after editors blocked his column defending Sophie Cunningham's stance on transgender athletes in women's sports, calling it a matter of journalistic integrity.
28 August 2026
2.6 MINS
Thomas Aquinas questioned Muhammad’s credentials to speak for God. His question remains uncomfortably relevant.
25 August 2026
10 MINS
When Sophie Cunningham's comments on transgender athletes in women's sports went viral, a WNBA sideshow became something bigger: a clash between two rival stories about creation, identity, and redemption.
24 August 2026
1.9 MINS
Five Sydney Swans players face serious allegations after a hotel party scandal. But watch how quickly "five players" became "all men" — without a shred of extra evidence.
24 August 2026
7.6 MINS
A controversial UK government guide telling asylum seekers about sexual consent has sparked fierce criticism over immigration, public safety and government accountability.
