Identity Politics Exploits Decency and Compassion
This is a simple, yet profound, insight:
“Identity politics wins not by making compelling arguments, but by exploiting the inherent decency of the American people.”*
I think too often people on the Right diagnose the success of identity politics by virtue of negative factors, like venality, cowardice, self-interest, perverse incentives.
I think these negative factors can be identified in individuals, and even in some institutions, on a case-by-case basis. But I don’t think they work as universal or generalised diagnostics.
Modern Morality
The average punter, in my view and my experience, plays along with the agenda (more often dictates) of identity politics out of a genuine desire to do the right thing, treat people well and be a good citizen.
I have also found that if one takes the time to critique identity policies with this average (good-willed) punter, one can pretty easily change their mind.
(I don’t bother with activists. They are a waste of time. The battle will be won or lost in the majority non-ideologically aligned middle).
*Source: Jonah Goldberg, Suicide of the West.
___
Originally published on Dr Jonathan Cole’s page.
Subscribe to his podcast, The Political Animals, for more insights.
Photo by Gotta Be Worth It.
Recent Articles:
14 October 2026
5.5 MINS
As Christianity fades from public life, Marxism or Communism offers a substitute faith built on oppression, liberation and political salvation — but at what cost?
9 October 2026
1.8 MINS
Pen Power Australia has been busy confronting antisemitism and double standards, lodging letters, pursuing accountability and celebrating several important wins along the way.
8 October 2026
3.6 MINS
John Anderson warns that Australia’s decline is rooted in spiritual and cultural disintegration, calling for a recovery of Christian foundations, social cohesion and national purpose.
7 October 2026
1.5 MINS
Across the Middle East, North Africa and Anatolia, Christianity once shaped entire civilisations. Could Britain’s Christian heritage likewise become a memory rather than a reality?
7 October 2026
8.5 MINS
Gerald McDermott’s work challenges Christians to approach Israel through Scripture first, exploring God’s covenant faithfulness, Christian Zionism, Jewish identity and antisemitism.
6 October 2026
6.2 MINS
Britain’s grooming gang scandal exposes a devastating failure to protect vulnerable children, raising urgent questions about political correctness, accountability, immigration and the loss of moral courage.
5 October 2026
4.9 MINS
Free Speech Union co-founder Reuben Kirkham warns Australia’s proposed Digital Duty of Care could expand censorship powers, undermine free expression and bypass recent legal protections.
