Identity Politics Exploits Decency and Compassion
This is a simple, yet profound, insight:
“Identity politics wins not by making compelling arguments, but by exploiting the inherent decency of the American people.”*
I think too often people on the Right diagnose the success of identity politics by virtue of negative factors, like venality, cowardice, self-interest, perverse incentives.
I think these negative factors can be identified in individuals, and even in some institutions, on a case-by-case basis. But I don’t think they work as universal or generalised diagnostics.
Modern Morality
The average punter, in my view and my experience, plays along with the agenda (more often dictates) of identity politics out of a genuine desire to do the right thing, treat people well and be a good citizen.
I have also found that if one takes the time to critique identity policies with this average (good-willed) punter, one can pretty easily change their mind.
(I don’t bother with activists. They are a waste of time. The battle will be won or lost in the majority non-ideologically aligned middle).
*Source: Jonah Goldberg, Suicide of the West.
___
Originally published on Dr Jonathan Cole’s page.
Subscribe to his podcast, The Political Animals, for more insights.
Photo by Gotta Be Worth It.
Recent Articles:
4 October 2024
3 MINS
Penny Wong's deft touch — by which I mean her total abandonment of moral clarity — has become a unifying touchstone for all Australians. By insisting Israel has a right to defend itself, she angers the Muslims. And then, by cleverly chastising Israel every time they defend themselves, she angers the Jews.
26 September 2024
3.8 MINS
Seattle street preacher Matthew Meinecke was forcibly removed by police at a pro-abortion protest and a PRIDEFest rally in 2022. Attendees abused and physically assaulted Meinecke. Instead of arresting Antifa and the LGBTQ+ self-identifiers involved, Seattle police detained the pastor.
25 September 2024
3.1 MINS
Family First is officially back. After being voluntarily deregistered as a political party in 2017, the party that began life in March 2004 has re-entered politics in 2024. The Australian Electoral Commission approved Family First’s application on 20 September.
18 September 2024
1.7 MINS
A man who threw hot coffee over a 9-month-old baby escaped authorities thanks to political correctness. Police asked the public to help them locate the man they described as “tan”. They left it up to us to guess that “tan” meant “Asian”.
-
16 September 2024
4.2 MINS
The recent disturbing violence in Melbourne at first made me angry and then very sad. Is this what Australia has become? Gird your loins: the battle is just beginning.
11 September 2024
3.4 MINS
This is the problem that afflicts modern Western culture. We are more concerned about protecting a group’s feelings than about genuinely helping them.
-
11 September 2024
7.3 MINS
In "Bad Therapy: Why the Kids Aren’t Growing Up", Shrier examines the huge mental health crisis that our young people are experiencing. And much of the “therapy” that most children are receiving is simply making matters worse.
