
Dawkins, Euthanasia and Eugenics
Richard Dawkins is the gift that just keeps on giving. Well, at least for us religious types who believe in God and hold to a Judeo-Christian worldview. Dawkins consistently makes the alternative look downright ridiculous. Take for instance one of his most recent tweets on the effectiveness of eugenics:
It’s one thing to deplore eugenics on ideological, political, moral grounds. It’s quite another to conclude that it wouldn’t work in practice. Of course it would. It works for cows, horses, pigs, dogs & roses. Why on earth wouldn’t it work for humans? Facts ignore ideology.
— Richard Dawkins (@RichardDawkins) February 16, 2020
For someone who has pronounced himself as one of the world’s ‘brights’, it’s difficult not to perceive this statement as anything less than dim-witted. In particular when one understands the historic link between social Darwinism and eugenics, which especially underpinned the philosophy of Nazi Germany.
Is it just me, or does anyone else find it more than a little ironic that someone like Dawkins would invoke a rule named Godwin’s Law to defend himself from any such connection? And to be fair, Professor ‘Bright’ quickly qualified his position, tweeting:
For those determined to miss the point, I deplore the idea of a eugenic policy. I simply said deploring it doesn’t mean it wouldn’t work. Just as we breed cows to yield more milk, we could breed humans to run faster or jump higher. But heaven forbid that we should do it.
— Richard Dawkins (@RichardDawkins) February 16, 2020
But this is just a classic bait-and-switch which Dawkins is known for so often doing. Just take, for example, his defence regarding mild forms of paedophilia. But as an avowed atheist, why invoke such a thing as ‘heaven’ as an authority? It sure is difficult to be consistent when you reject a belief in any power brighter than yourself. As Allie Beth Stuckey in response tweeted:
However, the underlying problem with Dawkin’s argument is that he has explicitly advocated for a eugenic strategy involving babies with Downs Syndrome.
I don’t think the guy who thinks it is immoral to give birth to a Down’s baby could argue against eugenics on a moral level. pic.twitter.com/VUQST50rzx
— Simon Reye (@SimonReye) February 17, 2020
With New South Wales set to debate euthanasia laws later this year, now is the time to take stock of what some of the ramifications will almost certainly be. As former Prime Minister Paul Keating has rightly argued in The Sydney Morning Herald:
An alarming aspect of the debate is the claim that safeguards can be provided at every step to protect the vulnerable. This claim exposes the bald utopianism of the project – the advocates support a bill to authorise termination of life in the name of compassion, while at the same time claiming they can guarantee protection of the vulnerable, the depressed and the poor.
No law and no process can achieve that objective. This is the point. If there are doctors prepared to bend the rules now, there will be doctors prepared to bend the rules under the new system. Beyond that, once termination of life is authorised the threshold is crossed. From that point it is much easier to liberalise the conditions governing the law. And liberalised they will be. Few people familiar with our politics would doubt that pressure would mount for further liberalisation based on the demand that people are being discriminated against if denied. The experience of overseas jurisdictions suggests the pressures for further liberalisation are irresistible.
Ethicist Professor Scott B. Rae argues in Moral Choices: An Introduction to Ethics (Zondervan, 2018):
… eugenics and euthanasia share some points of commonality—namely, the notion that some people are “useless eaters,” a phrase being resurrected today, and the idea that someone could be a human being but not be a full person with inalienable rights to life. Both should be causes for alarm, prompting us to reconsider the way the elderly are viewed today.
So, yes all forms of eugenic policy should be deplored. But in the light of Dawkins’ previous statements regarding people with disabilities, it’s difficult to take his outrage seriously.
[Photo by Sam Wheeler on Unsplash]One Comment
Leave A Comment
Recent Articles:
20 November 2026
4 MINS
Israelis are calling for a boycott of Australian products following Labor’s latest sanctions against Israeli settlers, while reports suggest Israel may consider counter-sanctions.
20 November 2026
2.1 MINS
A satirical legal battle exposes the absurdity of separating Hamas’s political and social activities from its military wing, using Hitler’s imagined defence to make the point.
20 November 2026
3 MINS
The Snowy Hydro scheme has ballooned from a $2 billion nation-building promise to a potential $42 billion financial disaster, exposing serious failures in planning, governance and accountability.
19 November 2026
4.5 MINS
Amanda Flavell is campaigning for Swiss-style direct democracy in Australia, giving citizens greater power to challenge legislation and influence decisions on climate policy, censorship and women’s rights.
19 November 2026
5.5 MINS
Influential Christian artist Steve Camp, who passed away at age 71, believed that Christian music could become incredibly successful at serving believers while simultaneously losing its power to reach the rest of the world. He explained exactly why in a striking interview back in 1988.
19 November 2026
2.5 MINS
Ben Carroll struggled to distance himself from Labor’s troubled 11-year record in a bruising leaders’ debate, while Jess Wilson looked every inch a Premier-in-waiting.
18 November 2026
2.9 MINS
Australia’s proposed digital duty of care bill aims to protect children online, but Catholic and Anglican bishops warn its vague provisions could threaten religious freedom and free speech on the internet.













































He much longer do we do nothing meaningful against the assault on human life. How do they justify it.