‘Dark Emu’ Exposed as Shoddy Indigenous History; Whistleblower Josephine Cashman Vindicated
Written by Bruce Pascoe in 2014, Dark Emu claimed to recover a forgotten history of Indigenous Australia. Pascoe’s book asserted that before European colonisation, Aboriginal communities were not ‘hunter-gatherers’ but used complex farming practices, baked bread, built houses, lived in large settlements and invented democracy. Dark Emu even claimed that this history goes back 120,000 years — twice that of current scholarship.
The book sold a quarter of a million copies and attracted some of Australia’s most prestigious literary awards, including Book of the Year and the Indigenous Writers’ Prize in the NSW Premier’s Literary Awards, and the Victorian Premier’s Literary Award for Indigenous Writing. Dark Emu has since inspired a children’s book and a stage play, and is being taught in Australian schools.
But Pascoe’s scholarship is shoddy. And this week, even the newspapers that once defended him have acknowledged as much. The piece published by both The Age and the Sydney Morning Herald drew national attention:
Two leading Australian academics have savaged the best-selling Indigenous history book Dark Emu for being riddled with mistakes, accusing its author Bruce Pascoe of lacking “true scholarship” and ignoring Aboriginal voices.
In a new book, Farmers or Hunter-Gatherers? The Dark Emu Debate, anthropologist Peter Sutton and archaeologist Keryn Walshe claim Professor Bruce Pascoe’s work is “littered with unsourced material”, uses selective quotations and exaggerates “weak evidence”…
Until recently, those who raised concerns about Bruce Pascoe and Dark Emu have been dismissed by the corporate media as agitators and even racists. Aboriginal businesswoman Josephine Cashman was among many to critique Pascoe — including his shaky claims of Indigenous ancestry.
At the time she spoke up, Cashman was serving as a senior advisor to Federal Indigenous Affairs Minister Ken Wyatt. She produced a letter denouncing Pascoe from an Indigenous elder which the elder later withdrew and claimed was false. Following these events, Wyatt dismissed Cashman from her advisory role, saying her position was “no longer tenable”.
But according to Josephine Cashman, there was a simpler reason Ken Wyatt sacked her. “I think I was asking too many questions,” she told Andrew Bolt on this week’s The Bolt Report. She continued:
I’m a proud Australian and I was taking the responsibility of being selected to such a senior committee very seriously. And I was asking a lot of questions because there is — and it’s a fact — a lot of corruption in Aboriginal organisations… As a person who wants to do the right thing for all Australians, I felt I had an obligation to ask these questions.
On the show, Andrew Bolt labelled Dark Emu “Australia’s greatest literary hoax” and he called on Ken Wyatt to apologise for promoting Bruce Pascoe and for sacking Cashman for blowing the whistle on him.
Ken Wyatt has stood by Pascoe’s claims to Indigenous ancestry. “If Bruce tells me he’s Indigenous, then I know that he’s Indigenous,” Wyatt has told reporters. “He would not be making that claim knowing that he would know both of his family lines.”
Josephine Cashman disagrees. “How can we have an Aboriginal voice to Parliament when we’re potentially being run by fake Aboriginals with an ideology?” she asked Andrew Bolt.
Beginning in 2020, Cashman has been speaking up on behalf of Indigenous communities hurt by the corruption within what she dubs the ‘Aboriginal industrial complex’. She warns that decisions are being made by just a handful of players while communities on the ground are not being properly consulted.
Cashman is also concerned that Pascoe’s shoddy scholarship is being used to drive a wedge between Indigenous and non-Indigenous Australians. Any critique of Dark Emu is met with the suggestion that “people are uncomfortable about looking at Aboriginal people in a different light”. Pascoe scolds his critics, claiming, “Some people are so fixated with Aboriginal incapacity that any thought of a sophisticated Aboriginal civilisation undermines the validity of the colony itself.”
In other words, if you question Pascoe’s book, you’re a racist. This manipulative rhetorical device makes use of the same ideology currently causing deep divisions the United States.
“I prefer to be on the side of truth,” Cashman told Bolt. She feels that Australians can be proud for resisting the unnecessary divisions seen in other countries. “I am really pleased… that this hasn’t denigrated into an ‘us-against-them’ debate… I think it shows a level of maturity in Australia.”
One Comment
Leave A Comment
Recent Articles:
13 December 2024
2.5 MINS
Australia’s government is yet to respond to calls to protect children from chemical castration drugs that are now banned in five European nations and half the United States.
13 December 2024
5.3 MINS
Yesterday, a Melbourne Federal Court judge ruled in favour of expelled Liberal Party member Moira Deeming. Victorian Liberal leader John Pesutto was found guilty of having defamed Deeming, having smeared her as a neo-Nazi.
13 December 2024
5.8 MINS
The new Moderna factory opened in Victoria this week with the promise of pumping out up to 100 million doses of mRNA vaccines per year, amid rising vaccine hesitancy and unresolved safety concerns.
12 December 2024
3.2 MINS
Speaking with 2GB, Dutton said that if the LNP wins next year’s election, the only flag he’ll stand in front of is Australia’s National Flag, the blue ensign.
12 December 2024
6.8 MINS
Since I began teaching in the early 1950s in Queensland, I have seen unbelievable changes in education. In writing this article I am thinking of the new generation of five-year-olds now starting their formal education. Nothing is as important as their learning to read.
11 December 2024
0.9 MINS
It is extremely distressing that the Queensland Parliament yesterday passed a motion from Premier David Crisafulli which bans discussion of abortion in Parliament for the next four years.
11 December 2024
2.7 MINS
Are our authorities serious about cracking down on anti-Semitism in the wake of Friday morning’s terror attack? There’s an easy way to find out. Arrest those idiots chanting for violence against Jews in Sydney on Sunday.
For Dark Emu being published is a disgrace.
Research and studies show that aborigines roamed the land, lived in caves or under trees, ate witchetty grubs, blew into hollow logs and did not have the intellect to light fires – carrying fire sticks from one area to another. They raped and plundered the land, causing extinction of much flora and fauna through overuse.
Mungo Man remains is the EARLIEST aborigine in Australia and is between 17000 to 24000 years so media and black propaganda saying over that time frame is wrong.
Yvonne Baker B.A Litt.B LL.B Grad Dip Legal Train.(Leo Cussen, Melbourne, Victoria)
Barrister and Solicitor Supreme Court of Victoria. (retd)…..
p.s. Please do not keep repeating the 65000 year time frame of black habitation in Australia. This propaganda destroys the credibility of SBS and makes you look ignorant of TRUE aboriginal history in this country.