The Necessity of Private Property Ownership
I came across this fascinating argument from William of Ockham in the deliciously named On The Tyrannical Ascendancy of the Pope (early 1340s):
“But after sin, because among men there grew up avarice and the desire to possess and use temporal things wrongly, it was useful and expedient that temporal things should be appropriated and not all be common, to restrain the immoderate appetite of the wicked for possessing temporal things and to drive out neglect of the proper management and administration of temporal things, since common affairs are commonly neglected by bad men.”
The argument (more extensive than this single quote), is that “temporal things” were held in common pre-Fall (i.e., common ownership), which worked because without sin, property was used wisely and according to need. This of course makes common ownership the state of perfection in a pre-Fall world.
Preventing Sin
Interestingly, private ownership (putting this in modern language) arises as a consequence of the Fall, but not because it is intrinsically sinful, but because it is a necessary way of addressing sin lest the common property be misused (by the greedy) and/or neglected (by freeloaders).
Thus, while private ownership was not a part of the good creation, it is a “good”, after a kind, designed to adapt to the emergence of avarice and neglect.
He obtained the neglect argument from Aristotle’s famous critique of Plato’s common property argument (all the way down to wives and children) for the guardian class in The Republic based on the insight that people do not value, and therefore care for, things which they do not own as much as they do for the things they do own (still one of the best arguments for private property ever advanced).
___
Originally published on Dr Jonathan Cole’s page.
Subscribe to his podcast, The Political Animals, for more insights.
Photo by Zen Chung.
One Comment
Leave A Comment
Recent Articles:
31 October 2026
3.8 MINS
Awakening begins when we remember the love that awakened our hearts in the first place.
30 October 2026
4.5 MINS
A Tasmanian Christian reflects on 42 years of faith, warning that proposed conversion practices laws could threaten prayer, parenting and religious freedom, while reaffirming his hope in Christ.
30 October 2026
3.7 MINS
Christian leaders who deny the persecution of their own communities can obscure the truth, distort Western perceptions of Islam and leave vulnerable believers without a voice.
30 October 2026
3.5 MINS
Awakening begins when we remember the love that awakened our hearts in the first place.
29 October 2026
2.7 MINS
If passed, the Digital Duty of Care Bill 2026 will almost certainly lead to censorship of Bible-based convictions about marriage, abortion, gender, Islam and more. Here's why it should be rejected and how to make a submission by 30 October.
29 October 2026
3.4 MINS
Professor of Law Dr Joanna Howe is taking her employer to the Federal Court after an alleged 11-month in-house investigation into her public pro-life advocacy.
29 October 2026
4.6 MINS
Personal liberty cannot flourish without good manners and respect for others. Drawing on J.S. Mill and historic reformers, this piece explores freedom, peaceful protest and the common good.
The prospect of owning my own home was paramount to me. And so I do . I could never have envisioned the day when the State (et al ) could simply take it .
None the less I do not regret that particular decision because it proves beyond doubt that home ownership is possible regardless of background….unless of course one chooses victim status.