Bid to Protect NSW Faith-Based Aged Care from Euthanasia Fails
A bid to protect the religious freedom of faith-based aged care facilities in New South Wales was rejected in the Upper House on 19 November by 23 votes to 16. But the issue could be raised in an upcoming statutory review of voluntary assisted dying laws.
Liberal MLC Susan Carter’s private member’s bill would have given residential facilities the same right that hospitals have to decline euthanasia and assisted suicide on their premises, while requiring them to provide alternative arrangements for residents.
Under the existing law, residents of aged care facilities may access all stages of the VAD process on-site.
This goes further than similar laws in Victoria, Western Australia, and Tasmania, which all allow protections for faith-based aged care facilities.
Go Gentle Australia and Dying with Dignity NSW contended that the bill was an attack on the rights of people at the end of life.
But others, including Archbishop Anthony Fisher OP, urged supporters to get behind the bill and ask their Upper House representatives to protect freedom of religion and the right of people of the same faith to live together in a way that respects their values and beliefs.
Upcoming Review
Legal euthanasia and assisted suicide have been operating in NSW for close to two years, with a statutory review due to begin after 28 November.
Minister for Mental Health Rose Jackson, speaking on behalf of herself and Minister for Health Ryan Park, told parliament they would oppose the bill and that the “appropriate forum” to explore the issues it raised was via the statutory review.
“Legislative change has not been ruled out as an outcome of this review process,” she said.
Carter told The Catholic Weekly she was disappointed people who voted against the bill didn’t seem to appreciate the impact VAD provision in an aged care home has on the other residents.
“It’s their home as well, and having VAD administered there starts to change the culture of a faith-based facility,” she said.
“Given the assurances during this debate, we look forward to seeing this issue being included in the statutory review.”
The first annual report showed that 398 people died in the first seven months of the state’s VAD regime.
Backing Down
In Victoria, the government’s proposed reforms to aggressively expand its VAD laws were significantly limited thanks to two amendments passed on 14 November.
One, moved by Labor MP Michael Galea, removed the ability of registered health practitioners, including dentists, podiatrists, and Chinese medicine practitioners, to initiate conversations about VAD.
The other, moved by Labor MP Ryan Batchelor, on the rights of conscientious objectors, was similar to an earlier proposal from Liberal MP Erin Mulholland. It narrows the scope of the minimum information that must be provided by a medical practitioner.
“These two amendments, I think, signal the government will always go as far as what they think they can get away with politically, and they have acknowledged under pressure that they may have overstepped in what appears to be an embarrassing backdown,” Mulholland told parliament during the debate.
“I am pleased that sensible heads on both sides of this debate have prevailed in, I think, gutting some of the worst aspects of this bill.”
___
Republished thanks to The Catholic Weekly. Image courtesy of Adobe.
3 Comments
Leave A Comment
Recent Articles:
19 June 2026
3.5 MINS
One Nation’s “Fire the liar” rebuttal to Labor’s “fight the far-right” fundraiser has gone primetime. The clever return to sender was aired at least twice during Wednesday’s State of Origin game.
19 June 2026
3.7 MINS
Hon Maryka Groenewald asked the Cook Government to commit to protecting Christians’ right to express their faith freely. The Attorney General’s office dodged the question, instead pledging “balance” for WA’s “diverse” population.
19 June 2026
4.3 MINS
A rape gang report has revealed that at least 250,000 white British girls were subjected to repeated rape, trafficking, torture, and forced Islamic conversion by networks of predominantly Pakistani Muslim men. Around 87% of those convicted bore distinctively Muslim names.
19 June 2026
7 MINS
Nation First reports on Pauline Hanson’s National Press Club showdown and how the media, GetUp and the Liberals all helped prove her point.
19 June 2026
6.4 MINS
The FBI has uncovered a terrorist group of 19 individuals planning a terror attack on the White House on 14 June. But the FBI only learned of the threat because a family in Ohio became concerned about their son’s behaviour and alerted authorities.
19 June 2026
6.5 MINS
The West was repulsed by the Holocaust perpetrated by the Nazi Regime against the Jews in WWII. Yet, it can find itself aligning with an underlying anti-Semitism that can be traced back to an error in an understanding Scripture first made by early Church leaders.
18 June 2026
3.6 MINS
History was made last night. Last night showed that the pro-life movement is capable not merely of resisting change, but of advancing its own positive vision for the protection of human life.
Such an important issue, especially for the prevailing peace of residents.
Thank you Marilyn.
accept the public money, accept the public standards
“It’s their home as well, and having VAD administered there starts to change the culture of a faith-based facility,” she said”
It would, it would be a corrosion slowly normalising the secular way that the life of a human is equal to that of an animal.
It would be horrifying in my mind to know someone that was living in the same aged care as I was in and knew, was about to be put down like an animal. God says when I die and how I die. I just 2 days ago underwent cancer surgery, in my recovery room I was with an elderly gentleman whom is not going to have much time left, colon cancer with a bag he just had surgery to have fitted and liver cancer. He told me he knows he’s done. To try and imagine if I was there and learnt after even that brief time 2 days with him and hearing about his wonderful life that they, say, would then wheel him out of the room to another to put him down like a dog would in my mind be like something out of a horror science fiction movie. The very thought or notion is utterly horrifying! Shame on our Govts for this animalistic approach to end of life. They’re Satanic.