Has The New York Times Always Been ‘Fake News’?
Hunter Biden’s laptop, the Wuhan lab leak and the Trump-Russia collusion hoax are just some of the fake news stories published by The New York Times in recent years. But actually, the Gray Lady’s fling with fake news goes back almost a century.
The New York Times is widely regarded as the newspaper of record in the United States. Founded in 1851 to appeal to a cultured, intellectual readership rather than a mass audience, the Gray Lady has won a record-breaking 137 Pulitzer Prizes, including for its reporting on the infamous Pentagon Papers.
In times of sharp political polarisation, however, the reputation of the Times, like many other outlets, has suffered significant damage. Arguably, much of this is self-inflicted, with the paper increasingly setting aside its iconic moniker “All the News That’s Fit to Print” in pursuit of activist journalism.
As I previously highlighted at Intellectual Takeout, countless legacy press outlets have earned their “fake news” status through years of dishonest reporting on too many matters of national interest. The Times is as culpable as any in myriad scandals: the Russia collusion hoax, Hunter Biden’s laptop, denying the origins of the COVID-19 virus, and many more.
It’s a sordid record. However, what readers might be surprised to learn is that, for The New York Times at least, this record stretches back over more than 90 years.
Fake News and the Holodomor?
One of the Pulitzer Prizes awarded to the Times went to Walter Duranty, the paper’s Moscow bureau chief for the first 14 years (1922–1936)” of Josef Stalin’s bloodthirsty reign in the USSR.
Far from receiving the prize for exposing Stalin’s cruelty, Duranty earned his stripes by effectively covering up the regime’s worst atrocities, including the Holodomor—the manmade Soviet famine that killed some four million Ukrainians.
As explained by NPR:
Duranty was The New York Times’ man in Moscow, as the line went, with a cushy apartment in which to entertain expatriates and a reputation as a leading authority on the Soviet Union. Duranty had staked his name on the idea that Josef Stalin was the strong leader the communist country needed. He is often credited with coining the term ‘Stalinism.’
In return, Duranty won rare interviews with Stalin and wrote glowingly about Stalin and his plans. The Pulitzer board cited his ‘dispassionate interpretive reporting’ in awarding him a prize in 1932 for a series of reports the previous year. The first was a front-page article that started with the line: ‘Russia today cannot be judged by Western standards or interpreted in Western terms.’
In truth, between 1932 and 1933, Stalin’s henchmen carried out a campaign of forced collectivisation and grain confiscation in order to crush Ukrainian resistance to Soviet power. Helpless, Ukrainians survived on rodents and wild plants until even these food sources dried up and millions succumbed to starvation.
Rather than carry out his journalistic duties, Duranty swallowed Soviet propaganda whole and laundered it for consumption by a naive Western public.
It took until the 1980s for The New York Times to acknowledge Duranty’s crooked journalism. Even then, the Times never apologised for it or returned the Pulitzer Prize, preferring to pass the blame, writing on its website, “The Pulitzer board has twice declined to withdraw the award, most recently in November 2003, finding ‘no clear and convincing evidence of deliberate deception’ in the 1931 reporting that won the prize.”
Fake News About the Holocaust?
The Gray Lady deserves comparable criticism for its underreporting on the Holocaust. According to Laura Leff, a journalism professor at Northeastern University, “No American newspaper was better positioned to highlight the Holocaust than the Times, and no American newspaper so influenced public discourse by its failure to do so.”
The Times had 30 reporters stationed in Europe during World War II who were well-placed to fully expose the Holocaust. Leff argues that, while the paper did publish around 1,200 articles relating to the topic, only 26 of its 24,000 wartime front pages were dedicated to the most devastating genocide in history, and most of those failed to report on the Nazi’s specific targeting of Jews.
What is the lesson for us today?
As the famed Fourth Estate, the media has an essential role to play in safeguarding the American republic. When it fails at this duty, everyone suffers.
The 2020s present consumers of news media with a critical choice. When papers like The New York Times have demonstrably deceived the public on so many occasions, will we use discernment going forward? Where will we go for the truth?
Be warned that many once-trusted institutions have been co-opted in the culture war.
Most importantly, read today’s headlines knowing they could be next century’s retractions.
___
Republished with thanks to Intellectual Takeout. Image courtesy of Unsplash.
One Comment
Leave A Comment
Recent Articles:
4 November 2024
6.2 MINS
The effort to blast away the ability of the Internet to have a verified history fits neatly into the stakeholder model of information distribution that has clearly been prioritised on a global level.
4 November 2024
1.5 MINS
The Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet recently published its independent inquiry into the COVID-19 Response in Australia. More, not less, bureaucratic control seems to be the theme of the report. A Royal Commission is well overdue.
4 November 2024
2.7 MINS
As Australia’s electricity system which charges EVs is overwhelmingly powered by fossil fuels, particularly coal, it is disingenuous to say that more electric vehicles will lead to a reduction in emissions.
4 November 2024
6 MINS
As even non-believers understand, the November 5 election in the United States will be hugely significant – for good or ill. Believers especially need to think clearly and biblically about all this.
1 November 2024
3.6 MINS
Anthony Albanese’s alternative to a COVID Royal Commission has recommended Labor create a centralised source for information and control during a public health crisis.
1 November 2024
6.1 MINS
I do not now use the term "detransition" because, after seeing all of this research, I realised that nobody ever truly transitions, so nobody can detransition. I prefer to say that I got my real life back.
1 November 2024
5.8 MINS
A horrific terror attack occurred in late July in Southport, England, where three children were stabbed to death at a Taylor Swift-themed dance class. But any talk of this being an Islamic terror attack was quickly squashed by police, the elites, and the mainstream media.
Very revealing article. Sad that their heritage of lies goes back so far!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!