OpenDAEN COVID-19 adverse events

OpenDAEN: Making Sense of the TGA’s Covid Adverse Event Reports

19 July 2024

5.7 MINS

It was a dinner table conversation imprinted in my memory. The date: September 2021. Topic: Covid injections. Discussion: robust. With the mandatory vaccination deadline looming, I argued that mandates violated someone’s ability to give their consent because there was pressure, coercion, and manipulation. Also, people couldn’t give fully informed consent to a product that had been around for less than a year, as the risks were not yet entirely known.

My colleague argued that the injections had been through rigorous safety testing, the risks were known, and any unknowns would be picked up by the TGA through their closely monitored Database of Adverse Events Notifications system. If there were concerns, we would be informed about them.

Maybe at an earlier time in my life, I would have felt similarly reassured. But you only need to understand a little of the history of medicine and the pharmaceutical industry to know that we are not good at picking up and acting on safety signals – think thalidomide, smoking, and any of a vast array of medications that have been removed from market sometimes decades after approval. Neither is the pharmaceutical industry a ‘model’ operator, with some pretty serious convictions and criminal fines in recent history.

Concerning

So, when the rollout started in 2021, I was scanning the horizon for concrete reassurance. I wasn’t the only one. Research analyst Sharon Cousins was watching closely, too. Over the past three years, Cousins, along with a team of volunteers, has been on a journey of data discovery that has resulted in the creation of a startling resource for Australians.

She tells her story:

As a member of the public, I was concerned about the fast pace of the Covid vaccines being produced. Contacts of mine in the UK mentioned adverse reports being listed on the UK Government system called the ‘Yellow Card’, and I followed these and the reports in Israel and the USA, because they started these trial vaccines ahead of us, before the rollout in February 2021 in Australia.

I was concerned when I saw a publicly available report – the European Medicines Agency (EMA) Assessment report on the Pfizer product, Comirnaty. Because I’ve had breast cancer (twice), I wanted to see if the Pfizer Covid jab had been tested for cancer.

The EMA Assessment Report on Comirnaty is a 140-page document dated the 19th of February 2021. Lo and behold, on page 55, it states: ‘No genotoxicity nor carcinogenicity (cancer-causing) studies have been provided.’ Then on page 115, I was very alarmed to see a whole table list called ‘Summary of Safety Concerns’.

The list Cousins found contained important identified risks – anaphylaxis, and important potential risks. This also included vaccine-associated enhanced disease, vaccine-enhanced respiratory disease, and a whole section called ‘missing information’.

‘Missing information’ included use in pregnancy, breastfeeding, immunocompromised patients, frail patients with co-morbidities, and patients with autoimmune or inflammatory disorders. The report also listed ‘long term safety data’ as ‘missing information’.

A similar list can be found on page 31 in the TGA’s Public Assessment Report dated January 2021, along with the decision, ‘Approved for provisional registration’.

Forgive me while I pause and ask the obvious.

If the safety information on our most vulnerable was missing at the time of the rollout, why wasn’t this made known to the public and the medical profession? Also, how can informed consent be possible if a patient is not made aware of these ‘known unknowns’?

Resounding Silence

In April 2021, with this information in hand, Cousins contacted the TGA’s Advisory Committee on Vaccines to voice her concerns. She is still waiting to hear back.

The TGA’s Covid-19 Vaccine Safety and Monitoring page makes clear the role of the TGA with regard to vaccines:

‘The Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) is responsible for monitoring the safety of all vaccines approved for use in Australia. We closely assess safety data prior to approval and continue to monitor the safety of vaccines after they are registered in Australia so that we can detect and respond to any safety concerns. This is known as pharmacovigilance.’

From the beginning of the Covid injection rollout in Feb 2021, the TGA began monitoring the adverse event reports through its Database of Adverse Events Notification (DAEN) system. The TGA describes DAEN – medicines as ‘our online database that contains information from suspected adverse events reported to us for medicines, vaccines and biological therapies’.

They continue:

‘We use information from these adverse event reports to detect unusual or unexpected patterns in the data which may indicate a safety signal related to a product. This passive signal detection surveillance system relies on people reporting an adverse event that they suspect is linked to a medicine.’

The TGA makes clear that ‘inclusion in DAEN – medicines does not mean that the adverse event has been confirmed or that it was caused by a medicine or vaccine’ and ‘there might be no relationship between the adverse event and the medicine. The symptoms may instead have occurred coincidentally’.

Regarding the reported deaths, the TGA states, in its final safety report on the Covid injections in November 2023, ‘The TGA has identified 14 reports where the cause of death was linked to vaccination from 1,004 reports received and reviewed (as of October 29, 2023). There have been no new vaccine-related deaths identified since 2022.’

Noted.

To date, there have been almost 140,000 adverse event reports entered to DAEN for the Covid injections, including 1,010 reported deaths.

At this point, you may be interested to know that the number of adverse events reported for the Covid injections amounts to around 20 per cent of all adverse events reported to the TGA – for all medicines combined – for the past 50 years.

Now, I’m no statistician but even if only a fraction of these reports are found to be ‘causal’, this looks like a safety signal to me, and I have questions.

Many have argued, ‘There have been millions of doses, and therefore, you would expect a lot of reports.’ That may be so. However a ‘passive surveillance’ system is only as good as the reports that are entered, and a significant under-reporting factor needs to be considered and has been reported in the literature. Anecdotally, I have been told many accounts of people suffering a suspected adverse event only to be refused to have their concerns acknowledged by their doctor, let alone added to the DAEN as a report.

(It may encourage the reader to know that anyone – member of the public, health care professional, patient, or family member – can report a suspected adverse event to a therapeutic product here.)

Transparency

Back to the DAEN. Anyone who has tried to navigate DAEN will have discovered it is not the most user-friendly interface. For example, it is difficult to find and identify demographics, patterns of adverse events, or even reported deaths. With less than 20 per cent appearing to have the batch number recorded, it is also challenging to ascertain whether particular batches are associated with higher numbers of reports, as has been found overseas.

Enter the Freedom of Information request process.

‘I requested and paid for a TGA Freedom of Information document entitled FOI 4077,’ Cousins tells me.

‘It was published on the TGA FOI Disclosure Log website in December 2022. I asked for all the Covid vaccine TGA DAEN case numbers of reported deaths and their doses and batch numbers from the 10th of January 2022, which was when they started jabbing the 5–11-year-old children in Australia, up until the time of my request, which was November 8, 2022.’

What Cousins found alarmed her. Even with only a fraction of batch numbers provided, two batch numbers stood out – FL5333 associated with six reported deaths, and FP1430 associated with two reported deaths. By searching the DAEN system, Cousins found the case numbers for the two FP1430 recipients, two boys aged ten and five.

Cousins hasn’t been the only one requesting further information via the FOI process. There has been a virtual army of researchers requesting additional data from the TGA, and the full FOI disclosure log can be found here.

This is information that – in my opinion – should be made more freely available to the public and the medical profession. There’s good news, it now IS!

Thanks to Cousins and a team of volunteers, the TGA’s entire, published, database of adverse event notifications for the Covid injections is now available on a user-friendly, easily searchable platform called OpenDAEN. Created through hundreds of hours of meticulous, painstaking work, each report has been entered and cross-matched with additional information obtained through the FOI process. Take a look:

OpenDAEN

OpenDAEN allows for easy research of adverse event reports including serious cases, patterns of adverse events, product brand, and batch numbers where available. I have no doubt this invaluable resource will bring a fuller picture of Australian Covid adverse event reports, to the public, the medical profession, and the government. In addition, OpenDAEN will help inform consent discussions like never before.

___

Republished with thanks to The Spectator Australia. Image courtesy of Adobe.

We need your help. The continued existence of the Daily Declaration depends on the generosity of readers like you. Donate now. The Daily Declaration is committed to keeping our site free of advertising so we can stay independent and continue to stand for the truth.

Fake news and censorship make the work of the Canberra Declaration and our Christian news site the Daily Declaration more important than ever. Take a stand for family, faith, freedom, life, and truth. Support us as we shine a light in the darkness. Donate now.

2 Comments

  1. Sharon 21 July 2024 at 2:39 pm - Reply

    Thanks Dr. Julie Sladden and The Daily Declaration for reposting this article (originally published 2.2.24 – The Spectator) and to my friend, Dianne for letting me know about this article link by recent email.

    Since Feb. 2024, the number of adverse reports listed on the TGA DAEN (Database of Adverse Event Notifications) as at 21.7.2024 is 140,745 for COVID-19 jabs, which includes 1,024 deaths reported (9 of which are Australian children aged 5 to 17).
    Notably, following the Channel 7 Spotlight program “After COVID” which was aired on Sunday 30.06.2024, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oyEOb341a28 (fast forward to 27mins for adverse injuries/deaths and @ 41mins for Dr Kerryn Phelps etc.), there was a significant increase in the number of COVID jab cases reported on the TGA DAEN. We had been seeing an average 20-40 cases reported weekly, but a staggering 80 cases were reported for one week up to 5.7.2024 (as at 19.7.2024) including another miscarriage (termed ‘Abortion spontaneous’). 310 miscarriages have been reported following these COVID-19 experimental injections on the TGA DAEN, plus an additional 11 foetal deaths and 17 stillbirths.

    But what about the underreporting factor? As the Harvard Pilgrim Health Care 2011 report states “fewer than 1% of vaccine adverse events are reported”. Multiply these Australian TGA DAEN reported case number figures by 100 to get 1% e.g. 140,745 x 100 = 14mil+ cases (maximum estimate). Or multiply by x 10 to get a minimum number of cases i.e. 140,745 x 10 = 1.4mil+ cases. NB. Watch out for the ‘paid’ Fact Checkers on this.

    With regards the “Summary of Safety Concerns” identified in early 2021 by the EMA (European Medicines Agency) for the AstraZeneca (Vaxzevria), Pfizer (Comirnaty) and Moderna (Spikevax), here are the publicly published assessment report links with specific page numbers of these “safety concerns”, as evidence of the risks known, but not made publicly known to the Australian and global public. NOT SO ‘SAFE & EFFECTIVE’.

    AstraZeneca (dated 29.1.2021)
    https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/documents/assessment-report/vaxzevria-previously-covid-19-vaccine-astrazeneca-epar-public-assessment-report_en.pdf#page142

    Comirnaty (Pfizer dated 19.2.2021)
    https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/documents/assessment-report/comirnaty-epar-public-assessment-report_en.pdf#page115

    Moderna (Spikevax dated 11.3.2021)
    https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/documents/assessment-report/spikevax-previously-covid-19-vaccine-moderna-epar-public-assessment-report_en.pdf#page127

    With respect to Dr Julie Sladden’s link in this article to the TGA Public Assessment Report dated 25.01.2021 on the Pfizer (Comirnaty) 42 pages https://www.tga.gov.au/sites/default/files/auspar-bnt162b2-mrna-210125.pdf – I had not seen this report until this Daily Declaration article 19.07.2024.

    I have listed below the key pages from this TGA 25.1.2021 Comirnaty (Pfizer) report for quick scrolling and to help people who have been vax-injured or known vax deaths, following the Pfizer mRNA experimental jab – given “provisional approval” by the TGA’s ACV (Advisory Committee on Vaccines).

    Page 19 – List of study trial participants excluded (notably those with reactions i.e. anaphylaxis risk).
    Page 28 – Adverse Events (Lymphadenopathy, Hypersensitivity & Facial paralysis i.e. Bell’s palsy).
    Page 29 – Deaths in trial and 49 of 100 trial participants aged 12 to 15 recruited in Phase II/III plus anaphylaxis cases already reported in UK and USA.
    Page 31 – Summary of Safety Concerns (which mirrors page 115 of the EMA Assessment Report link above)
    Page 34 – Data limitations and “Missing Information”
    Page 35 – Anaphylaxis, Hypersensitivity and “Provisional registration” by the “Delegate”
    Page 37 – ACV (Advisory Committee on Vaccines)
    Page 38 – Aged care and “Do not shake” to be listed on PI (Product Information)
    Page 41 – Temperatures -90C to -60C and batch analyses

    Please visit https://opendaen.info for the weekly updated database on the COVID jabs adverse events reported which includes batch number and reaction term search engines etc. Also use/share this link for resource information https://opendaen.info/other-info-resources

    Rgds,
    Sharon

  2. Sharon 22 July 2024 at 10:43 pm - Reply

    Thanks Dr. Julie Sladden and The Daily Declaration for reposting this article (originally published 2.2.24 – The Spectator) and to my friend, Dianne for letting me know about this article link by recent email.
    Since Feb. 2024, the number of adverse reports listed on the TGA DAEN (Database of Adverse Event Notifications) as at 21.7.2024 is 140,745 for COVID-19 jabs, which includes 1,024 deaths reported (9 of which are Australian children aged 5 to 17).
    Notably, following the Channel 7 Spotlight program “After COVID” which was aired on Sunday 30.06.2024, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oyEOb341a28 (fast forward to 27mins for adverse injuries/deaths and @ 41mins for Dr Kerryn Phelps etc.), there was a significant increase in the number of COVID jab cases reported on the TGA DAEN. We had been seeing an average 20-40 cases reported weekly, but a staggering 80 cases were reported for one week up to 5.7.2024 (as at 19.7.2024) including another miscarriage (termed ‘Abortion spontaneous’). 310 miscarriages have been reported following these COVID-19 experimental injections on the TGA DAEN, plus an additional 11 foetal deaths and 17 stillbirths.
    But what about the underreporting factor? As the Harvard Pilgrim Health Care 2011 report states “fewer than 1% of vaccine adverse events are reported”. Multiply these Australian TGA DAEN reported case number figures by 100 to get 1% e.g. 140,745 x 100 = 14mil+ cases (maximum estimate). Or multiply by x 10 to get a minimum number of cases i.e. 140,745 x 10 = 1.4mil+ cases. NB. Watch out for the ‘paid’ Fact Checkers on this.
    With regards the “Summary of Safety Concerns” identified in early 2021 by the EMA (European Medicines Agency) for the AstraZeneca (Vaxzevria), Pfizer (Comirnaty) and Moderna (Spikevax), here are the publicly published assessment report links with specific page numbers of these “safety concerns”, as evidence of the risks known, but not made publicly known to the Australian and global public. NOT SO ‘SAFE & EFFECTIVE’.
    AstraZeneca (dated 29.1.2021)
    https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/documents/assessment-report/vaxzevria-previously-covid-19-vaccine-astrazeneca-epar-public-assessment-report_en.pdf#page142
    Comirnaty (Pfizer dated 19.2.2021)
    https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/documents/assessment-report/comirnaty-epar-public-assessment-report_en.pdf#page115
    Moderna (Spikevax dated 11.3.2021)
    https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/documents/assessment-report/spikevax-previously-covid-19-vaccine-moderna-epar-public-assessment-report_en.pdf#page127
    With respect to Dr Julie Sladden’s link in this article to the TGA Public Assessment Report dated 25.01.2021 on the Pfizer (Comirnaty) 42 pages https://www.tga.gov.au/sites/default/files/auspar-bnt162b2-mrna-210125.pdf – I had not seen this report until this Daily Declaration article 19.07.2024.
    I have listed below the key pages from this TGA 25.1.2021 Comirnaty (Pfizer) report for quick scrolling and to help people who have been vax-injured or known vax deaths, following the Pfizer mRNA experimental jab – given “provisional approval” by the TGA’s ACV (Advisory Committee on Vaccines).
    Page 19 – List of study trial participants excluded (notably those with reactions i.e. anaphylaxis risk).
    Page 28 – Adverse Events (Lymphadenopathy, Hypersensitivity & Facial paralysis i.e. Bell’s palsy).
    Page 29 – Deaths in trial and 49 of 100 trial participants aged 12 to 15 recruited in Phase II/III plus anaphylaxis cases already reported in UK and USA.
    Page 31 – Summary of Safety Concerns (which mirrors page 115 of the EMA Assessment Report link above)
    Page 34 – Data limitations and “Missing Information”
    Page 35 – Anaphylaxis, Hypersensitivity and “Provisional registration” by the “Delegate”
    Page 37 – ACV (Advisory Committee on Vaccines)
    Page 38 – Aged care and “Do not shake” to be listed on PI (Product Information)
    Page 41 – Temperatures -90C to -60C and batch analyses
    Please visit https://opendaen.info for the weekly updated database on the COVID jabs adverse events reported which includes batch number and reaction term search engines etc. Also use/share this link for resource information https://opendaen.info/other-info-resources
    Rgds,
    Sharon

Leave A Comment

Recent Articles:

Use your voice today to protect

Faith · Family · Freedom · Life

MOST POPULAR

ABOUT

The Daily Declaration is an Australian Christian news site dedicated to providing a voice for Christian values in the public square. Our vision is to see the revitalisation of our Judeo-Christian values for the common good. We are non-profit, independent, crowdfunded, and provide Christian news for a growing audience across Australia, Asia, and the South Pacific. The opinions of our contributors do not necessarily reflect the views of The Daily Declaration. Read More.

MOST COMMENTS

GOOD NEWS

HALL OF FAME

BROWSE TOPICS

BROWSE GENRES