Big Tech Won’t Police Itself
Despite many grillings in Congress, the heads of Big Tech companies are doing little to protect children online. There is no other way: tough legislation is now required.
The problems with social media, like harming minors with sexual content, won’t fix themselves, especially with the CEO’s ignoring them.
Ruth Institute President Dr Jennifer Roback Morse charged social media companies like TikTok, Snapchat and YouTube with being “wildly disingenuous.”
“Whenever they’re called before Congress, they claim they’re doing their utmost to protect minors from sexual content. But their protestations are meaningless,” Morse said.
Indifference From Big Tech
At last week’s hearing before the Senate Commerce Subcommittee on Consumer Protection, Product Safety and Data Security, executives of the three social media giants were grilled by sceptical senators on both sides of the aisle about these problems with social media.
Morse remarked: “It’s rare when Republicans and Democrats can get together on anything. But they agreed about the seeming indifference of High Tech when it comes to protecting minors from corrupting influences.”
Utah Senator Mike Lee revealed that his staff had set up a Snapchat account for a fictitious 15-year-old. Someone that age is supposed to be protected from ads and content with sexual content. But the fictional teen’s page included invitations to play online sexualised video games, articles by porn stars and ‘helpful hints’ for visiting bars. Lee said the content could most politely be described as “wildly inappropriate for a child.”
A Moment of Reckoning for Social Media
When faced with concrete evidence of negligence or wrongdoing, representatives of these companies have a routine response. Michael Beckerman, Head of Public Policy at TikTok America, said, “Sex and drugs are violations of our community standards; they have no place on our site.”
Morse replied: “Big deal. Despite TikTok’s solemn disavowals, the content is there for anyone to see. What is TikTok doing about it? Nothing.”
Calling it “Big Tech’s… moment of reckoning,” Senator Edward Markey (D. MA) asked the executives if they would support bipartisan legislation that would give minors more privacy rights and ban ads and targeted video autoplay for children. All three equivocated.
“Could their insincerity be any more obvious?” Morse asked. “This hearing proves, as if further proof was necessary, that this is an industry unable or unwilling to police itself. Bring on the bi-partisan legislation.”
Originally published at the Ruth Institute. Image by McKaela Taylor on Unsplash.
About the Author:
Recent Articles:
13 May 2025
3.8 MINS
Hannah Murfy was at last week's anti-Greens' abortion bill rally in Sydney. Recently pregnant, she tragically lost her baby, which strengthened her conviction against dehumanising the unborn. Contact your MP today, as the bill could be voted on any time from Tuesday, 13 May.
13 May 2025
1.9 MINS
We are constantly told that “left” and “right” are poles apart politically. But this careless use of language implies that everyone’s political ideas fit somewhere between the ideas of two cruel socialist dictators.
-
13 May 2025
2 MINS
The culture war is really an argument over what is real and what is not. Perhaps, in Pope Leo XIV, we may have a leader who advocates for reality over the unreality promoted by popular culture and political elites.
-
13 May 2025
3.8 MINS
The US Department of Health and Human Services has released a landmark report warning that 'gender-affirming' procedures for children are medically unproven, risky, and ethically questionable.
12 May 2025
2.9 MINS
In an Australia first, the ACT Labor government is considering assisted suicide for patients who lose decision-making capacity — alarming pro-life groups who have long warned of a slippery slope regarding euthanasia.
-
12 May 2025
4.8 MINS
In the aftermath of Pope Francis' death, I read much from people who had anointed themselves either his Catholic defenders or his critics. Some critics said nothing positive; defenders, nothing negative. The truth is in the middle.
-
12 May 2025
2.6 MINS
SCOTUS has upheld the Trump Administration's decision to remove transgenderism from the US Military, finding no reason to deny the US government's policy of "Prioritising military excellence and readiness".
