Victoria: Utility vs Freedom
Some are saying the Victorian election result was rigged. It wasn’t. This isn’t Arizona. The only reason someone could be shocked at the Victorian election outcome is if they misjudged Australians to be freedom-loving. Aussies like freedom, but they don’t love it. They can live without it.
The truth is that Aussies tend to see government as a “vast public utility” that helps us and makes our lives easier. They don’t see government as a freedom-enhancing institution, but as a utility-enhancing one.
And what is more useful than being kept “safe” from a deadly virus? Well, nothing! And who is more deserving of punishment and derision than those citizens who minimise the threat of this virus and even put others’ lives at risk by not doing what they’re asked? No one!
In other words, Dan delivered on utility: he kept people “safe” and therefore earned re-election. As I’ve said many times, Aussies have a cynical attitude to politicians, but an optimistic attitude to government: we basically trust it (even if we won’t explicitly admit it).
What this means is that Australians won’t be very moved by warnings of state tyranny, or particularly fussed when the state actually is a tyrant — not while it’s delivering on utility. I’m not trying to demoralise; I’m just describing things as I think they are.
Does this mean there is no hope for freedom? Not necessarily. It just means that the fight against tyranny may be less a strategy of popular politics than other methods: lawfare, raising new elites, etc.
___
Originally published on Twitter. Photo: Donald Y. Tong/Wikimedia Commons
Recent Articles:
28 September 2026
6.1 MINS
Australia’s proposed Digital Duty of Care bill promises greater online safety, but its sweeping surveillance, speech and regulatory powers raise serious questions about liberty.
28 September 2026
4.3 MINS
The NSW Government has rejected proposed hate speech law expansions, following pressure from the ACL and others defending free speech and religious liberty.
28 September 2026
2.2 MINS
A Royal Commission into the Bondi terror attack must confront every plausible source of antisemitism, while Christian leaders should not retreat from difficult questions.
25 September 2026
3.1 MINS
Australian and New Zealand mounted troops continued their Holy Land campaign beyond Beersheba, culminating in the fierce battle at Semakh and the defeat of Ottoman forces by the Australian Lighthorse and the New Zealand Mounted Rifles.
25 September 2026
6.7 MINS
Monica Smit celebrates the abolition of Victoria’s Group Voting Ticket system while setting her sights on mandatory voting, sparking a fresh debate over electoral reform.
25 September 2026
3.5 MINS
Labor and the Greens voted down a motion by Moira Deeming MP that would have banned children from being present during in-person commercial sex work, including in private homes.
25 September 2026
1.9 MINS
The Church is God's choice to reach Australia. But is the Church largely asleep? Join the Canberra Declaration during 72 hours of prayer and worship to renew our love for God and prepare for 31 days of prayer for the Church in October.
