
No Christmas Card from the Liberal Leader
It seems I have upset Opposition Leader Peter Dutton.
The Liberal Party leader wrote a scathing letter, published in The Spectator, about an article I wrote quoting his comments concerning sacked Essendon CEO Andrew Thorburn.
Here is Mr Dutton’s letter to The Spectator:


I would make a couple of points.
Firstly, I did acknowledge in my article that Mr Dutton condemned the treatment of Mr Thorburn.
I wrote:
“He said the media and political pile-on that forced Andrew Thorburn from the job he held for just 24 hours was ‘an egregious attack’ on religious freedom.”
Morality
Secondly, Mr Dutton is right that I suggested he was aligned with Daniel Andrews — not on the issue of Mr Thorburn’s sacking, but in describing orthodox Christian beliefs on sexuality and the sanctity of life as “an abomination”.
I wrote:
“But then Dutton suddenly felt the urge to outdo Daniel Andrews in vilifying Christianity, no small feat.
‘It was like Dutton, having listened to Andrews deride Christianity as ‘absolutely appalling’, told the Victoria Premier: “Hold my beer…”
The Liberal leader, turned theologian, told Sky News Australia:
‘The views that have been expressed by a pastor at this church in relation to gay people, or to the issue of abortion — they’re an abomination and I condemn those points that have been made by that particular pastor.’”
Andrews described Christian views on homosexuality and abortion as ‘absolutely appalling’. Dutton described them as ‘an abomination’.
Judge for yourself whether they sound aligned or not.
Abortion and Genocide
Third, I did not misrepresent Mr Dutton’s comments at all. I quoted directly from a Sky News report on October 5 that read:
‘The Opposition Leader directly condemned the views held by City on a Hill but said the resignation was a result of an “egregious attack” on his religious beliefs.
‘”The views that have been expressed by a pastor at this church in relation to gay people, or to the issue of abortion — they’re an abomination and I condemn those points that have been made by that particular pastor,” he said.’
Mr Dutton complained to The Spectator that in quoting his comments, I had misrepresented them. He wrote:
‘In strongly backing Andrew Thorburn, I did, however take exception to Pastor Guy Mason’s reference to “concentration camps” in his 2013 sermon, because that was something that jarred with me.’
Mr Dutton is referring to this comment from Pastor Mason:
‘Whereas today we look back at concentration camps, future generations will look back with sadness at the legal murder of hundreds of thousands [sic] human beings every day through medicine in the name of freedom.’
If that is what Mr Dutton was taking exception to in his comments to Sky News then I would argue that it is not me who has misrepresented Mr Dutton — it is the Liberal leader who has misrepresented Pastor Mason.
Read again what Mr Dutton said, as quoted by Sky:
‘The views that have been expressed by a pastor at this church in relation to gay people, or to the issue of abortion — they’re an abomination and I condemn those points that have been made by that particular pastor.’
No mention of “concentration camps” there. And if that’s what he meant, why include the church’s views on “gay people”, which had nothing to do with the pastor’s reference to concentration camps?
Freedom of Religion / Christian Ethics
I am glad that Mr Dutton has affirmed for readers of the Spectator his commitment to religious freedom. Many of us are counting on the Liberals to do so, because we certainly don’t trust Labor to uphold religious freedoms.
But I did not question Mr Dutton’s commitment to religious freedom. What I did point out was that by describing the orthodox Christian position on sexuality and abortion — held by many Liberal voters — as “an abomination”, Mr Dutton was severely undermining his base.
For the record, I like Mr Dutton, and I desperately hope he will be a successful conservative leader. God knows the country needs him to be!
But Mr Dutton would be better off clarifying his own clumsy remarks — if indeed that’s what they were — rather than attacking me for accurately reporting what he said and then coming to the exact same conclusion that most other people of faith came to after reading his remarks.
___
Originally published at The James Macpherson Report.
Subscribe to his Substack here for daily witty commentary.
Photo: Wikimedia Commons
3 Comments
Leave A Comment
Recent Articles:
17 November 2026
2.9 MINS
Australian singer-songwriter Jonathan Bone is breaking new ground with a bold pro-life anthem, created alongside his teenage son, celebrating the dignity and value of unborn life.
17 November 2026
2 MINS
Australia’s AUKUS submarine deal faces another bizarre objection, with senior Navy officials warning that American military policies could exclude transgender and non-binary Australian personnel.
17 November 2026
4.6 MINS
As occult practices gain popularity, are churches equipped to confront spiritual darkness? Dr Barry Manuel urges Christians to recognise spiritual warfare and prepare for deliverance ministry.
17 November 2026
1.6 MINS
NSW Labor has devoted 31 pages of legislation to removing the pronouns "he" and "she" from state laws, raising fresh questions about its priorities and understanding of biological sex.
17 November 2026
3 MINS
Rising costs, business closures and rapid technological change are putting Australians under growing pressure. But smarter government, stronger communities and renewed purpose can help turn things around.
16 November 2026
3.6 MINS
Victorian police twice detained Rebel News reporter Avi Yemini while he covered a student anti-One Nation rally, raising serious questions about press freedom and policing.
16 November 2026
1.6 MINS
New ABS modelling has dramatically changed Australia's excess death figures, raising questions about the revised methodology, pandemic-era deaths and whether Australians are getting the full picture.






James, thank you for your analysis that highlights the Liberal’s loss of their traditional Christian conservative values. Perhaps Dutton may be rethinking his position despite his outward bluster that seeks to appeal to the electorate he has lost.
James you have clarified exactly what was said by all sides of the debate.
Did Dutton just have a press release handed to him by his staff, and blindly read it out, later to have buyer’s remorse?
What he said was downright disappointing to the point of wondering just what a conservative Christian could expect next from him.
Like you, I PRAY he doesn’t descend into Christian belief bashing.
Leave that to Andrews and the left.
The majority of our politicians have been such cowards on contemporary issues and like many Australians, I no longer count on them to represent Truth.
We the people are responsible for them being in power through our complacency and our addiction to comfort.