Labor Stifles Freedom of Speech with New Misinformation Bill
by Chris Baxter
Today is the darkest day for Freedom of Speech in Australian history. The Labor Party has introduced its revised misinformation legislation to Parliament. Having read the legislation and posted my interim thoughts throughout the day, here is a summary of why you should be extremely concerned about it.
The scope of the new MisDis legislation introduced by Labor today is truly dystopian – no less concerning than the Bill of last year in my view. There is very, very little it does not plan to control other than 1. media it already controls and 2. private messages (or small groups… pic.twitter.com/R0klkxNSPF
— Chris Baxter (@chrisbaxter41) September 12, 2024
State Control
This legislation creates a two-tier rule book for what Australians can say, depending on who they are. On the one hand, Government-approved “professional” media gets a free pass to publish whatever they want, and on the other, all sorts of punitive actions can be taken against platforms that allow citizen journalism.
The 2024 MisDis Legislation is going to be the slow death of citizen jounalism in Australia because only “professional” news content is being excluded from the onerous requirements of the legislation. Under Section 16(2)(b) the only opinions that will not be subject to constant… pic.twitter.com/FJF9CAUbYF
— Chris Baxter (@chrisbaxter41) September 12, 2024
Whilst the punitive measures are cleverly not directly aimed at authors, they are such that digital platforms will have no choice but to shadow-ban or otherwise silence those who persist with posting information the Government deems as misinformation or disinformation.
— Chris Baxter (@chrisbaxter41) September 12, 2024
The Government has also created mechanisms for the state to intrude within private chat groups that are beyond a threshold size that they will decide. A register of misinformation will be created and maintained by ACMA and published on their website. No doubt, this will become an important reference tool for institutionalising the Government’s narrative, if it is not already, within mainstream media and education.
I’ve got my hands on the “Communications Legislation Amendment (Combatting Misinformation and Disinformation) Bill 2024” (link below) and will be analysing it against the draft exposure Bill introduced last year to see exactly how the Australian Government intends to control our… pic.twitter.com/tiWhzbunvh
— Chris Baxter (@chrisbaxter41) September 12, 2024
Secret Police and Re-education
Of course, no totalitarian imposition on free speech is possible without threats to the individual, and so now any person who ACMA deems to have information in relation to what it regards as misinformation can be hauled before its “secret police” at threat of fines.
The 2024 MisDis legislation introduced today seems to turn ACMA into some form of Misinformation Secret Police! Clause 34(1) allows punitive civil penalities against any person who fails to cough up information or a document relating to whatever ACMA deems misinformation or… pic.twitter.com/NCZRGKZstJ
— Chris Baxter (@chrisbaxter41) September 12, 2024
Cunningly, the legislation also creates so-called “media literacy plans”, which I believe will be used to force digital providers to add Government-approved framing and contextualisation to people’s posts. The new law will apply to almost every type of digital content, including search engines and AI, because, of course, they couldn’t have AI wrong-think either.
One of the curious aspects of the new 2024 MisDis legislation introduced today is the requirement for Digital Platforms to implement so called “media literacy plans”. These plans are effectively controlled by the Australian Government under s22 (a) which can require the Digital… pic.twitter.com/0ED2wIDih4
— Chris Baxter (@chrisbaxter41) September 12, 2024
also: pic.twitter.com/iNhMysaaYn
— Chris Baxter (@chrisbaxter41) September 12, 2024
So many perspectives of ordinary Australians are soon to be silenced: from people who do not believe men can become women, to those who have doubts about the legitimacy of the banking system, through to those who have different perspectives on health, medicines and vaccines.
There’s an insidious definition of “Serious Harm” within the MisDis Legislation introduced by Labor today –
s14(b) You remember all those posts you shared within facebook groups questioning the Covid orthodoxy? Or was that a family member who shared it? Doesn’t matter. You can… pic.twitter.com/SsskV4U5pJ
— Chris Baxter (@chrisbaxter41) September 12, 2024
The potential of a post creating “serious harm” is being set above freedom of political communication in Australia as of today.
Section 54 of the new misinformation legislation, introduced by labor today, porports to limit the legislation in relation to political communication.… pic.twitter.com/gwfgCqrYQY
— Chris Baxter (@chrisbaxter41) September 12, 2024
Finally, and most ironically, given the harms to democracy the legislation purports to address, the legislation unequivocally sets the need to mitigate “serious harm” above freedom of political communication. Australians have just been surrounded.
___
Chris Baxter is a Christian, husband and father to four young children who holds a deep concern for the civil liberties of fellow Australians. Working as a patent attorney, Chris has some familiarity with reading complex legislation and tries to use this skill to expose Australian Government overreach. Chris and his family attend Lane Cove Metropolitan Baptist Church and he advises his family’s charitable trusts.
Republished with thanks to Chris Baxter on X. Image courtesy of Adobe.
5 Comments
Leave A Comment
Recent Articles:
14 January 2025
2.9 MINS
Australia’s virtue signalling High Commissioner to the United Kingdom is doing a backflip, after a massive backlash. Stephen Smith, whose taxpayer-funded income is in the six-figure range, declared on Thursday that he would not be attending a key Australia Day function.
-
14 January 2025
3.2 MINS
A landmark health meeting will be presented with shocking figures on the number of people with severe psychiatric conditions who are receiving few or no services in the community, as ministers come together to formulate a national response to the nation’s growing mental health crisis.
14 January 2025
6.2 MINS
With a number of people dead and thousands of homes and businesses destroyed, the massive fires fuelled by strong winds in Los Angeles have been utterly devastating. The sad truth is this: California leaders and authorities were clearly quite unprepared for these fires.
14 January 2025
5.6 MINS
You probably wouldn’t know it by the legislation they pass and the debates they have, but Capitol Hill is one of the most religious places on earth.
-
13 January 2025
3.5 MINS
Errol Musk is predicating Tommy Robinson (Stephen Lennon) will one day be Prime Minister. Elon’s estranged and controversial father aired the not-so-batty point in an interview shared to X by The Times Radio on Tuesday.
-
13 January 2025
7.6 MINS
Depending on which echo chamber you get your news from, last week Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg took steps to either save democracy, or to end it. Zuckerberg announced several changes to Meta’s moderation approach, including replacing third-party fact-checkers with a user-driven Community Notes model.
13 January 2025
2.3 MINS
Where confusion over sexuality abounds today, the Australian Creed brings crisp clarity to this deeply personal and vitally important biblical teaching. And the impact of the creed is growing.
We started as a Penal Colony…. now we are descending into another 21st century version of being told that we are not free to think or speak anything that the Correction officers approve of.
Thankyou Chris. The way things are going in Australia at present feels like a mighty storm. Maranatha!
Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn in his “Warning to the West “( his speeches in 1975-1976 ) warned us what would happen if we ignored his warnings. Australia did ignore his warnings, and now we face the death of Free Speech. All we have left is Prayer and God to protect us. We are in more peril than in any other time in Australia’s history.
Solzhenitsyn was awarded the Nobel Prize for literature for “The Gulag Archipelago ” . According to a reviewer–” His message was that the West was veering towards moral + spiritual bankruptcy, becoming unfit to take a stand against tyranny + totaliatarianism”, Will the Australian govt. ban or burn his book as promoting “misinformation “+ “disinformation “? Lord Jesus Christ help us !
This is indeed a very sad day for our nation!
We really must write to our MPs about this if we are hoping to stop this. Check out the information from the Australian Christian Lobby or CitizenGo or find your own way to send your point of view before it is too late and becomes illegal for you to do so.