Progressives Also Seek Freedom — Just a Different Kind
The modern Left is not actually against freedom, like many on the Right think. The problem with the Left is that it stands for a very selective freedom, born of a binary view of society that divides all people into oppressed and oppressor classes.
The Left is actually obsessed with freedom, but only for those currently suffering under the bonds of oppression (in its view). The Left is not interested in maintaining, defending or sustaining the freedoms of those who it deems to belong to oppressor classes. If anything, these classes have too much power, which is to say too much freedom, which they use to oppress and marginalise minorities.
Neo-Marxism
It naturally follows that the oppressed classes, which objectively lack fundamental freedoms, according to the Left, can only increase their freedom at the expense of the oppressor classes, which have much more freedom than is due to any class.
This view is predicated on a conflictual view of society which says that the freedom of one individual can only come at the expense of another, which makes politics a zero-sum fight to win freedom for your particular sect, and bugger the others. Why would you stand up for the freedom of your opponents when you are locked in combat with them to control and inhabit the finite space that exists in any society to be free?
A better view is to begin with the inherent dignity of the individual, irrespective of class (real or imagined), and to seek to ensure, enshrine, protect and defend those individual freedoms to the greatest extent possible, seeking to balance conflicting freedoms in a prudential manner that does not work from the perverse logic that some individuals deserve more or less freedom depending on historical contingency and biological attributes that no individual chooses, nor can escape.
___
Originally published on Dr Jonathan Cole’s page.
Subscribe to his podcast, The Political Animals, for more insights.
Photo: BigStock
One Comment
Leave A Comment
Recent Articles:
23 September 2026
4 MINS
A renewed petition targets pro-life law professor Dr Joanna Howe, as she and husband James fight back against claims they say have damaged their careers and reputation.
23 September 2026
6.6 MINS
Government-funded research on boys, masculinity and the manosphere deserves rigorous scrutiny, especially when contested theories begin shaping education, regulation and public policy.
21 September 2026
4.4 MINS
On September 11, the Archbishop of Canterbury gave an interfaith award to a man who called Osama bin Laden the "Sword of God" and blames Jews and Christians for the war on Iran. The award was rescinded after public backlash.
21 September 2026
2.4 MINS
It is truly concerning that this sort of incursion into free speech can even be suggested. Labor's Digital Duty of Care Bill is about controlling the narrative online, and must be defeated.
18 September 2026
4.9 MINS
The government's $75 million deradicalisation program isn't working — and some wannabe terrorists have left more radical. So it's announced a new plan — which forbids identifying what's doing the radicalising.
18 September 2026
2.1 MINS
"Trans women are women." Repeat it enough and it starts to feel true. That's not an argument — it's a propaganda technique. And Australia's courts are now enforcing gender ideology.
17 September 2026
2.8 MINS
"A good mom if you strangle your kids — but lose custody for protecting your daughter from being castrated and mutilated by the gender lobby." That's Massachusetts today, where a Catholic couple lost their teenage girl for refusing to affirm her transgender identity.
Amen ! Thank you for your work Jonathan.