Cake Artist Jack Phillips Undergoes Third Court Case in 12 Years Defending His Religious Freedom
You might remember Jack Phillips, the man sued in 2012 for refusing to decorate a cake celebrating homosexuality. His persecutors are at it again.
Jack Phillips is a man of faith as well as a custom design cake specialist. However, due to Christian convictions, Phillips declined to make a cake that celebrated a same-sex wedding, which led to the cake designer being sued by the Colorado Civil Rights Commission (CCRC). As such, he’s now spent the last 12 years defending his religious freedom, with last week marking the third court case he’s gone through since this battle began.
The first case, which first occurred in 2012, wasn’t settled until 2018 when the U.S. Supreme Court ruled 7-2 in Phillips’s favour. And yet, only weeks later, CCRC sued him again when he declined “to create a custom cake celebrating and symbolising a so-called ‘gender transition,’” Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) summarised. However, those charges were dismissed after ADF attorneys filed a federal lawsuit. This brings us to the third case thus far, wherein Phillips was dragged back to court after the person who requested the “gender transition” cake took it upon himself to sue the decorator.
ADF, who has been representing Phillips, wrote that despite the longevity of these circumstances, “Jack is not backing down.” As the legal group expressed, “[O]ver the course of Jack’s legal journey, one thing has become abundantly clear: for some, it will never be enough to politely agree to disagree about important issues. … It wasn’t enough for Jack to lose a big part of his business after Colorado targeted him the first time,” nor “to have to defend his freedoms all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court,” nor “for Jack and his family to endure years of harassment and even death threats. For some, it won’t be enough until Masterpiece Cakeshop closes its doors. They want Jack, a quiet, hardworking cake artist, to pay a hefty price — all because he wants to express messages according to his faith.”
Jack Phillips is Not Alone
No final ruling has been issued from last week’s oral arguments, but Phillips and ADF Senior Counsel Jake Warner joined Family Research Council’s Jody Hice on Friday’s episode of “Washington Watch” to provide further insight to the case. As Warner emphasised, the arguments that took place last week “before the Colorado Supreme Court” advocated “free speech is for everyone.” He added, “[T]he government should not be able to force people like Jack to express messages they don’t believe.”
Hice posed the question: What are we to “make of this … continual, nonstop push that comes from the Left against people of faith?” Warner answered, “For the past 10 years or so, government officials and activists have been misusing state law to force people like Jack to express messages they don’t believe. It’s a misuse of the law.” And yet, even with the consistent pushback, Warner did note that, “thankfully, just last year, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 303 Creative [LLC v. Elenis] that the government can’t misuse the law to force people to say things they don’t believe.” Ultimately, he’s “hopeful” this is a step in the right direction, and “we hope that this harassment will stop once and for all.”
But as Hice pointed out, in addition to Phillips’s case, there are others who are also going through backlash for wanting to hold fast to their convictions. He asked Phillips, “What would you say to those who may be facing similar opposition across the country?” According to Phillips, it’s a matter of “know[ing] what your boundaries are and don’t step over them.”
As he explained, “[W]e serve everybody at Masterpiece Cakeshop, but we just aren’t able to express every message that people want us to with our custom cakes.” This is something the shop had decided “over 30 years ago” before they opened that certain cakes would be declined. “But it was always the message of the cake, not the person asking for it.” Hice also emphasised that when you have established values, it’s necessary to “stand up when they’re challenged.”
The Persecution of Jack Phillips
Considering how long Phillips has been persecuted, sued, and experiencing backlash, Hice asked how he could be prayed for. Phillips answered that first and foremost, “a lot of the prayers should go to the judges. They have a big task ahead of them. They want to get the decision right, and they want to make sure they write it all correctly so that the laws that they enforce here are laws that we can all live with, and freedom is maintained for all Americans.”
Hice agreed, noting that this case “impacts every one of us and it sets a pathway of religious liberties across our country.” As such, he added, “[W]hat kind of rippling effect might we expect” from whatever decision comes from the Colorado Supreme Court? “Well,” Warner stated, “certainly for the people in Colorado, a win for Jack would be a win for all people. It would confirm that Colorado officials cannot misuse state law to punish people that they disagree with. Free speech would truly be for everyone.”
He concluded, “Of course, if this case doesn’t come out the right way, we would appeal up to the U.S. Supreme Court, where we hope that the court would reaffirm 303 Creative’s holding that free speech is for everyone and put an end to this injustice.”
___
Republished with thanks to The Washington Stand. Image courtesy of Alliance Defending Freedom.
4 Comments
Leave A Comment
Recent Articles:
17 July 2026
15.2 MINS
The Church is wimpy, and it's destroying the nation. That's the blunt assessment of Rev. Chris Wickland, a UK clergyman who refuses to soften the gospel for perceived cultural acceptance. And he has a point. From the rise of "woke" institutional Christianity to the abdication of prophetic witness, the modern Church has traded its backbone for a desperate attempt to attain a disappearing seat at the table.
17 July 2026
4.5 MINS
Landlords have shut the door on the LGBTQ+ desecration of a former Sydney Catholic Church and theatre named after saints.
17 July 2026
2.2 MINS
Jillian Spencer, a Queensland psychiatrist suspended for questioning childhood gender treatments, has been cleared by AHPRA, as her hospital prepares to release its own statement.
17 July 2026
4 MINS
In a sign of the continuing breakdown of religious freedom in Europe, Finnish parliament member Päivi Räsänen was banned by the U.K. from traveling to Heathrow Airport for a planned layover due to her Finnish Supreme Court conviction in March for authoring a pamphlet containing supposed “hate speech” toward those who identify as LGBT.
17 July 2026
2.9 MINS
Questions on the environment produced the most lopsided results of any category tested, with every single model favouring climate concerns over growth. Removing one model’s “safety” layer moved its religion score from secular-leaning to neutral.
17 July 2026
4.7 MINS
As tensions between America and Iran escalate, foreign policy experts urge discernment in distinguishing between regimes that keep their word and those — like Tehran — that operate through deception and aggression, a lesson as old as Scripture itself.
16 July 2026
5 MINS
We're told that progressive politics equals compassion, inclusion and kindness. But shocking reactions to Ann Widdecombe's murder — celebrating her death and hoping she died in extreme pain — reveal the socialist left's blatant 'hate speech' hypocrisy and disturbing double standards of the highest degree.
We have seen the court system uphold injustice, where innocent people are accused and convicted of crimes they did not commit. One that stands out in my mind was Lindy Chamberlain, who, was arrested and jailed, then more than two years after the events of August 1980, was convicted in October 1982 of murdering her young baby Azaria, with no conclusive evidence and sentenced to life in prison. It took till June 2012 for all charges against her (and her husband “an accessory after the fact”) to be overturned and the Chamberlains received compensation for false imprisonment. There are many other unjust decisions that our courts have made. I choose to stand on righteousness, and to trust in God for justice, not any earthly system.
Amen Mac…I prayed through for the Lindy Chamberlain case and many did in Darwin. An aboriginal elderly man saw that dingo carrying the baby away in the night but he did not dare speak up openly about that sighting. That was finally released later on, (I saw the TV interview). May that miscarriage of justice teach the Australian court system that mistakes can be made and prejudice stirred up like bees in a swarm, once a wrong slant is taken on a case. The truth finally came out… Lindy was a good mother and it was known dingoes were lurking in the area.
The blindfolded lady, who once symbolised that justice was impartial, is now truly blind to the persecution of people of Faith around the World ( Africa, India, the Middle East, China ,and even part of Russia ) where churches, synagogues and homes are destroyed and people raped and killed because of their Faith. Moslems in Sydney and Melbourne are currently contemplating standing Independent candidates in Labor Ministers ‘ electorates at the next election. A coalition of the Greens/Teals/ Independents/ the Aboriginal elites + LGBTQ poses a threat to the continued peaceful existence of Christianity and Judaism in Australia. Vote them and this Labor government out if you value your Faith and freedoms.
Thank you Sarah for giving the update on this case. It was so wise of Philipps to say: “a lot of the prayers should go to the judges. They have a big task ahead of them. They want to get the decision right, and they want to make sure they write it all correctly so that the laws that they enforce here are laws that we can all live with, and freedom is maintained for all Americans.”
May we all keep praying for the judges, and for the courageous man Jack Philipps who has stood up for his Biblical values and for free speech.
He did this in a polite way and the ones wanting the cake made could easily have gone to another provider and asked them to make a cake instead. Instead of doing that the wedding cake clients have used issue to persecute Jack Philipps for his faith for over 12yrs!