
Strategic Morality: Why Tehran’s Islamists Get a Progressive Pass
A sharp critique of progressive double standards, arguing that Western opposition to Tehran sparks outrage—while the Iranian regime’s abuses are excused as “complex” and culturally nuanced.
It’s amazing what can awaken the modern progressive conscience.
For years, the regime in Tehran was busily perfecting the medieval arts…
Women were beaten for allowing a rebellious strand of hair to defy gravity.
Protesters were jailed, tortured, and occasionally shot for the inconvenience of dissent.
Gay men were introduced to the concept of “inclusivity” via prison cells or cranes.
The international Left responded with what can only be described as a thunderous hush.
But when Donald Trump so much as sneezes in the direction of Tehran, we’re suddenly hosting candlelight vigils for Iranian sovereignty.
One could be forgiven for thinking morality had taken a gap year.
Tactical Morality and Selective Outrage
Within a framework that believes in objective moral standards — those quaint relics suggesting that beating women and hanging homosexuals are bad regardless of geography — the Left’s posture makes no sense whatsoever.
When the Iranian regime oppresses its own people, the situation is “complex.” It requires nuance. Context. A podcast series.
But when the United States confronts that regime, we are informed that international law, sovereignty, and the fragile flower of peace have been brutally trampled by cowboy imperialists.
This disparity can only be understood if you forget that morality is fixed and imagine, as the Left do, that morality is tactical.
In the progressive cosmology, Western patriarchal capitalist Christian nations are not merely flawed; they are the axis upon which all historical evil rotates.
Colonialism, capitalism, climate change, gluten intolerance, bindies on the front lawn — all roads lead to the West.
Everyone else, by contrast, exists in a permanent state of victimhood.
Agency is for Europeans.
Blame is for Americans.
Everyone else gets explanatory footnotes.
Under this schema, Iran is not a theocratic regime that crushes dissent. It is a “regional actor.” A “counter-hegemonic force.” A “voice of the Global South.”
Its morality is, at best, culturally relative.
Its brutality is contextual.
Its slogans about wiping Israel off the map are regrettable but understandably emotive.
And if that regime happens to chant “Death to America”? Well, we all know they don’t mean “death” in the traditional sense.
“Liberating Tolerance” Weakening the West
This isn’t new.
Herbert Marcuse helpfully articulated the doctrine decades ago under the soothing title of “liberating tolerance.”
The theory is simple: tolerate movements that weaken Western power; withdraw tolerance from those that strengthen it. Tolerance, in other words, is not a virtue. It is a weapon.
Michel Foucault went one better and enthusiastically cheered the Iranian Revolution itself. Not because he had a secret fondness for clerical rule, but because he saw it as a blow against Western hegemony. The fact that the revolution would produce a regime that policed women’s wardrobes and executed dissidents was, apparently, an acceptable plot twist in the grand drama of anti-Western resistance.
This is the moral architecture of the Left.
If a regime opposes the West, it is complicated, textured, misunderstood. Its atrocities are framed as reactions. Its slogans are “rhetorical.” Its oppression is cultural.
If the West opposes that regime, it is aggression. Imperialism. Patriarchal capitalism flexing its colonial muscles yet again.
Do you notice what disappears in this equation? The actual Iranian people.
The women beaten in the streets for removing hijabs. The protesters dragged from their homes. The young men dangling from cranes as a warning to others.
The Left’s outrage, therefore, is not about human rights. It is about power. The Left are not concerned with justice, but with which civilisation is allowed to wield it.
Strip away the academic jargon, and what remains is disarmingly simple: whatever weakens the West is good. Whatever strengthens it is bad.
And if that means defending a regime that imprisons gays and brutalises women in the name of opposing American hegemony, well, pass the protest sign.
Without double standards, the Left would have no standards at all.
The real tragedy is that this isn’t merely intellectual theatre.
When morality becomes strategic rather than universal, the strongmen of the world learn a useful lesson: chant loudly enough against Washington, and half the Western intelligentsia will dutifully appear on the ABC to explain why your prison camps are culturally nuanced.
Civilisations do not collapse because their enemies are strong. They collapse because their moral confidence evaporates.
And nothing evaporates moral confidence faster than a worldview in which the only unforgivable sin is being the West.
___
Republished with thanks to The James Macpherson Report. Image courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.
2 Comments
Leave A Comment
Recent Articles:
18 November 2026
4 MINS
Halloween and funeral plans may help us confront the practicalities of death, but neither addresses the most important question: where will we spend eternity?
18 November 2026
2.9 MINS
Australia’s proposed digital duty of care bill aims to protect children online, but Catholic and Anglican bishops warn its vague provisions could threaten religious freedom and free speech on the internet.
18 November 2026
3.3 MINS
Britain’s proposed conversion therapy laws could criminalise parents, restrict Christian counsel and silence dissent, while a taxpayer-funded helpline’s actual call numbers fall dramatically short of claims.
17 November 2026
2.8 MINS
Australian singer-songwriter Jonathan Bone is breaking new ground with a bold pro-life anthem, created alongside his teenage son, celebrating the dignity and value of unborn life.
17 November 2026
2 MINS
Australia’s AUKUS submarine deal faces another bizarre objection, with senior Navy officials warning that American military policies could exclude transgender and non-binary Australian personnel.
17 November 2026
4.6 MINS
As occult practices gain popularity, are churches equipped to confront spiritual darkness? Dr Barry Manuel urges Christians to recognise spiritual warfare and prepare for deliverance ministry.
17 November 2026
1.6 MINS
NSW Labor has devoted 31 pages of legislation to removing the pronouns "he" and "she" from state laws, raising fresh questions about its priorities and understanding of biological sex.






Shows how stupid Westerners are to believe Leftist Woke rubbish which is why Australia is in grave danger of a takeover exactly the same as that which took over Iran in 1979 , and, without guns (as we are ) can do nothing to free themselves. It is the reason why I have never forgiven PM Howard and the LNP. For years I have begged we hold at least the minimum amount of oil that the international body recommends (90 days ), but, both Labor + LNP have ignored commonsense, and, in a few days (about 30 ) we could run out , and, then the whole of Australia (including planes) could grind to a halt ! A fractured society which does not prosecute and deport those people in Australia who eulogise a mass murderer, head of a regime which has been declared a Terrorist Organisation by our ally, the USA and the EU. WHY do we tolerate Terrorist cells living amongst us which have committed crimes against Jews unless we want to be the next Iran ruled by a brutal theocracy .
Very insightful. Thanks James for articulating truth so well.