NSW Abortion Bill: Making Doctors Complicit in Wrongdoing
Recently, debate commenced on the Abortion Law Amendment (Health Care Access) bill which would, amongst other things, further chip away at the freedom of health practitioners to conscientiously object to participating in abortion.
Currently, medical practitioners in Australia have only a limited right to express their conscientious objection. This is because they have a legal duty to perform an abortion in an emergency, notwithstanding that they might work in a Catholic hospital.
They also have a legal duty to refer a patient on to another medical practitioner whom they believe does not have a conscientious objection to the performance of the abortion.
In some states, including New South Wales, this duty to refer can be discharged in a special way that reduces the objector’s participation in abortion.
Instead of referring the patient to an abortion provider where the likelihood of abortion occurring would seem to be high, the law permits the objector to give information to the patient via a pamphlet (or otherwise inform her) of the services of the Pregnancy Choices Helpline and website.
This is a NSW government service that does not perform abortion, but provides information on “all options”. Accordingly, while it may assist a pregnant woman in finding an abortion provider, it may also assist her to get more support if she wishes to continue the pregnancy.
Known as a “third party” referral, it reduces the objector’s co-operation in any abortion that occurs and would be described by the church as material, indirect and remote participation in evil. In certain circumstances, this level of co-operation can be morally acceptable, such as where there are serious consequences for non-compliance.
Proximate Evil
The bill seeks to get rid of “third party” referral and replace it with “effective referral”. This requires objectors to share the intention of the abortion provider by locating and linking the patient up with someone who will perform that particular abortion. This is formal (implicit) co-operation in abortion and is something Catholics cannot do.
As history shows, authorities never start with imposing the most obvious and egregious form of co-operation in a particular evil on a conscientious objector. Rather, they move in increments so that people get used to making a small compromise here or there and experience a dulling of their conscience so it is easier to agree to the next level of compromise.
With abortion, they have required objectors to compromise through the current requirement for a “third party referral,” and now they wish to expand this to an “effective referral.” The final straw will be a duty on objectors to actually perform abortions or provide the prescription to obtain abortifacients so she can self-abort at home.
The contents of this bill should be distressing to all Catholic healthcare providers as well as the public at large. It undermines the concept of freedom of conscience and is a framework that can be used in the non-healthcare setting to impact other Catholic professionals. The Catholic Church and its canon law have much to say about conscience, abortion and complicity in wrongdoing.
The church should be teaching on these issues to its members, but lay people also have a duty to form their conscience and work out who or what is the ultimate authority for right and wrong. The church teaches that the education of the conscience guarantees freedom and engenders peace of heart.
___
Republished with thanks to The Catholic Weekly. Image courtesy of Adobe.
3 Comments
Leave A Comment
Recent Articles:
18 September 2026
4.4 MINS
Up to 10,000 rallied in Sydney for a ban on sex-selective abortion. Twenty-four hours later, the NSW Legislative Council defeated John Ruddick's bill 21–16. The fight, says Dr Joanna Howe, is just beginning.
18 September 2026
3.5 MINS
Brothers Luke and Joel Smallbone have become one of the world's most loved Christian pop acts. As For King & Country, they have won four Grammys, 15 GMA Dove Awards and billions of song streams. And today they releasing their latest album.
18 September 2026
4.9 MINS
The government's $75 million deradicalisation program isn't working — and some wannabe terrorists have left more radical. So it's announced a new plan — which forbids identifying what's doing the radicalising.
18 September 2026
2.1 MINS
"Trans women are women." Repeat it enough and it starts to feel true. That's not an argument — it's a propaganda technique. And Australia's courts are now enforcing gender ideology.
18 September 2026
5.2 MINS
Nike picked a fight with half its customers, endorsed a man in a sports bra, and defended China's slave labor. Now it's bleeding $200 billion in market value. Turns out customers have a choice.
17 September 2026
3.9 MINS
The NFL landed in Australia with a flyover, celebrities, and a 100,000-strong crowd. What caught the internet's attention was something the MCG hasn't seen much of lately: unashamed, public Christian faith.
17 September 2026
5.2 MINS
Surrogacy is often discussed through the hopes of adults seeking children. Meet the woman, born to a surrogate herself, who says the debate should begin instead with the experiences of surrogate mothers and children separated at birth.
Doing due diligence requires effort and some commitment to focus on the issue until it’s adequately understood.
It can be hard, unpleasant and even shocking work to become acquainted with “what’s really going on out there” in the (I dare say it) abortion industry.
Thank you Anna for providing this clear article.
We NEED TO KNOW what is going on, so that we CAN do something about it and pray about it from an informed place.
May our unfathomably merciful heavenly Father continue to bring truth into the open, and lead our nation and our people the way of truth, compassion and life.
A L A bill – A bout L egal A dvancement of B rutality.
The best way to defeat this insane extinction obsession is to marry and have as many babies as you’d love. Trust in God’s providence. The witness of happy large families defeats the anti-natalist propaganda.