An EU court case over baptismal records could pit data protection laws against religious freedom, raising serious questions about whether governments can compel churches to erase sacramental history.
Forcing churches to erase baptism records could become a reality if a European Union court rules that keeping records breaches general data protection laws.
Any such precedent has wide-reaching implications beyond Belgium, where the case originated.
The pressing question, which is applicable to all Australian churches, will be whether the precedent encourages the state to think it has the power to sanction the deletion of a sacrament.
He argued in First Things that an EU decision for the plaintiff “would fundamentally abridge the right of Christians in Europe to be Christians.”
“The historical fact of a baptism is undeniable; what that fact means and entails is none of the state’s concern.”
A Challenge to the Church’s Autonomy
“State involvement in such matters,” he wrote, “would ultimately interfere with a Christian’s right to practice his faith.”
“For example, the Catholic Church holds that a marriage between two Christians is a sacrament. Altering baptismal records would therefore invite sacramental sacrilege, since it would obscure whether a potential spouse is or is not a Christian, and thus whether the marriage is sacramental.”
“The state,” he added, “has no right to demand ecclesiastical amnesia on the part of the Church vis-à-vis those who seek sacramental marriage.”
Grondelski wrote, “Baptism is a fixed point. It is, theologically, adoption as a child of God. A child of God may abandon God, just as a natural child may flee his parents. Juridically, a court might even cancel parental rights. But no court can cancel parental facts: The parent-child relationship cannot be erased.
“The same is true of our adoptive relationship with Him ‘from whom all fatherhood in heaven and on earth takes its name’ (Ephesians 3:14–15).”
Known as C-12/25 Bisdom Gent, the case involves a Belgian man referred to as JM.
He was unsatisfied with the standard practice colloquially known as “unbaptism”, where the Church crosses off an individual’s name and notes their departure.
JM is demanding that the Catholic Diocese completely erase his 1955 baptismal record.
A press release from the EU Court of Justice explained that JM wants all references to him removed from the Roman Catholic Church’s register or archives. It said: “Instead of deleting his personal data, the diocese added a note in the baptismal register stating he had left the Church.”
Acting on a complaint from JM, Belgium’s Data Protection Authority ordered the diocese to erase the record.
The Church challenged the order, and a Brussels Court of Appeal has asked the EU court to clarify whether deleting JM’s name sits within its data protection legislation (the GDPR).
Can Data Protection Laws Erase Baptism?
The request also asks whether a note added to the baptismal register saying JM left the church was enough to satisfy the law.
In an opinion to the court published on 1 October, the Court of Justice’s Advocate General, Laila Medina, said that the GDPR applies, in principle.
Effectively, the Belgian Data Protection demand forcing the church to erase JM’s baptismal records appears to be within the boundary of the law.
The Church’s information contains personal data held within a structured filing system. Therefore, the regulations apply.
Medina wrote, “The autonomy of churches and religious organisations does not call this conclusion into question. Consequently, the data processing in question – its storage and, where appropriate, retrieval and use – must be in line with the GDPR.”
She added that balancing individual rights with religious freedom “cannot be carried out in the abstract.
“The national court must consider the specific circumstances of each case. In particular, the national court should take into account the reasons for the request for erasure and the possible impact of a refusal on the person concerned.”
“In that regard, the Advocate General notes that the continued retention of personal data by a religious community from which a person wishes to dissociate himself may affect that person’s right to self-determination and, in particular circumstances, cause emotional distress.
“In that regard, only a genuine reconciliation of the interests involved can ensure a fair outcome for those concerned.”
The Clash Between Individual Rights and Religious Freedom
Archiving is only an exception if it serves society, meets legal obligations and involves some form of access for government and the public.
Holding onto the data for future academic research purposes is only justifiable when and where it benefits society.
If the court rules that the further processing of personal data by the church is not justified, crossing out JM’s name is not enough.
Neither is adding a note saying he left the church. This doesn’t meet the GDPR’s definition of erasure.
Medina stated that: “The data must be rendered illegible to the extent necessary to ensure that the person is no longer identified or easily identifiable, while information concerning the fact that a baptism took place at a given place and time may be retained.
“This does not require the physical removal of pages from the register. Appropriate measures may be used to conceal the relevant data while leaving other information intact.”
There is no published reason for JM’s demand to have his baptismal record erased. However, the 2021 request was made at a time when Belgians were protesting the Vatican’s refusal to bless same-sex unions.
The significance of an EU outcome in favour of full erasure would pit EU law against Christians because baptism testifies to the core of Christian identity.
Catholic law makes the same point. As translated by Zenit, a Church statement appealing to canon law said, “A minister cannot permit the celebration of other Sacraments if the reception of Baptism is not verified.”
We need your help. The continued existence of the Daily Declaration depends on the generosity of readers like you. Donate now. The Daily Declaration is committed to keeping our site free of advertising so we can stay independent and continue to stand for the truth.
Fake news and censorship make the work of the Canberra Declaration and our Christian news site the Daily Declaration more important than ever. Take a stand for family, faith, freedom, life, and truth. Support us as we shine a light in the darkness. Donate now.
Israelis are calling for a boycott of Australian products following Labor’s latest sanctions against Israeli settlers, while reports suggest Israel may consider counter-sanctions.
A revised edition of "Unhumans" examines the history, tactics and ideological foundations of communist revolutions, warning of socialism’s growing influence and its hostility to Christianity.
A satirical legal battle exposes the absurdity of separating Hamas’s political and social activities from its military wing, using Hitler’s imagined defence to make the point.
The Snowy Hydro scheme has ballooned from a $2 billion nation-building promise to a potential $42 billion financial disaster, exposing serious failures in planning, governance and accountability.
International Men’s Day 2026 celebrates the contribution of men and boys, launches a landmark global report and calls for greater recognition, inclusion and equality.
Amanda Flavell is campaigning for Swiss-style direct democracy in Australia, giving citizens greater power to challenge legislation and influence decisions on climate policy, censorship and women’s rights.
The Daily Declaration is an Australian Christian news site dedicated to providing a voice for Christian values in the public square. Our vision is to see the revitalisation of our Judeo-Christian values for the common good. We are non-profit, independent, crowdfunded, and provide Christian news for a growing audience across Australia, Asia, and the South Pacific. The opinions of our contributors do not necessarily reflect the views of The Daily Declaration. Read More.
EU Court Adviser Opens Door to Erasing Baptism Records
12 October 2026
3.7 MINS
An EU court case over baptismal records could pit data protection laws against religious freedom, raising serious questions about whether governments can compel churches to erase sacramental history.
Forcing churches to erase baptism records could become a reality if a European Union court rules that keeping records breaches general data protection laws.
Any such precedent has wide-reaching implications beyond Belgium, where the case originated.
The pressing question, which is applicable to all Australian churches, will be whether the precedent encourages the state to think it has the power to sanction the deletion of a sacrament.
Theologian John Grondelski thinks so.
He argued in First Things that an EU decision for the plaintiff “would fundamentally abridge the right of Christians in Europe to be Christians.”
“The historical fact of a baptism is undeniable; what that fact means and entails is none of the state’s concern.”
A Challenge to the Church’s Autonomy
“State involvement in such matters,” he wrote, “would ultimately interfere with a Christian’s right to practice his faith.”
“For example, the Catholic Church holds that a marriage between two Christians is a sacrament. Altering baptismal records would therefore invite sacramental sacrilege, since it would obscure whether a potential spouse is or is not a Christian, and thus whether the marriage is sacramental.”
“The state,” he added, “has no right to demand ecclesiastical amnesia on the part of the Church vis-à-vis those who seek sacramental marriage.”
Grondelski wrote, “Baptism is a fixed point. It is, theologically, adoption as a child of God. A child of God may abandon God, just as a natural child may flee his parents. Juridically, a court might even cancel parental rights. But no court can cancel parental facts: The parent-child relationship cannot be erased.
“The same is true of our adoptive relationship with Him ‘from whom all fatherhood in heaven and on earth takes its name’ (Ephesians 3:14–15).”
Known as C-12/25 Bisdom Gent, the case involves a Belgian man referred to as JM.
He was unsatisfied with the standard practice colloquially known as “unbaptism”, where the Church crosses off an individual’s name and notes their departure.
JM is demanding that the Catholic Diocese completely erase his 1955 baptismal record.
A press release from the EU Court of Justice explained that JM wants all references to him removed from the Roman Catholic Church’s register or archives. It said: “Instead of deleting his personal data, the diocese added a note in the baptismal register stating he had left the Church.”
Acting on a complaint from JM, Belgium’s Data Protection Authority ordered the diocese to erase the record.
The Church challenged the order, and a Brussels Court of Appeal has asked the EU court to clarify whether deleting JM’s name sits within its data protection legislation (the GDPR).
Can Data Protection Laws Erase Baptism?
The request also asks whether a note added to the baptismal register saying JM left the church was enough to satisfy the law.
In an opinion to the court published on 1 October, the Court of Justice’s Advocate General, Laila Medina, said that the GDPR applies, in principle.
Effectively, the Belgian Data Protection demand forcing the church to erase JM’s baptismal records appears to be within the boundary of the law.
The Church’s information contains personal data held within a structured filing system. Therefore, the regulations apply.
Medina wrote, “The autonomy of churches and religious organisations does not call this conclusion into question. Consequently, the data processing in question – its storage and, where appropriate, retrieval and use – must be in line with the GDPR.”
She added that balancing individual rights with religious freedom “cannot be carried out in the abstract.
“The national court must consider the specific circumstances of each case. In particular, the national court should take into account the reasons for the request for erasure and the possible impact of a refusal on the person concerned.”
“In that regard, the Advocate General notes that the continued retention of personal data by a religious community from which a person wishes to dissociate himself may affect that person’s right to self-determination and, in particular circumstances, cause emotional distress.
“In that regard, only a genuine reconciliation of the interests involved can ensure a fair outcome for those concerned.”
The Clash Between Individual Rights and Religious Freedom
Archiving is only an exception if it serves society, meets legal obligations and involves some form of access for government and the public.
Holding onto the data for future academic research purposes is only justifiable when and where it benefits society.
If the court rules that the further processing of personal data by the church is not justified, crossing out JM’s name is not enough.
Neither is adding a note saying he left the church. This doesn’t meet the GDPR’s definition of erasure.
Medina stated that: “The data must be rendered illegible to the extent necessary to ensure that the person is no longer identified or easily identifiable, while information concerning the fact that a baptism took place at a given place and time may be retained.
“This does not require the physical removal of pages from the register. Appropriate measures may be used to conceal the relevant data while leaving other information intact.”
There is no published reason for JM’s demand to have his baptismal record erased. However, the 2021 request was made at a time when Belgians were protesting the Vatican’s refusal to bless same-sex unions.
The significance of an EU outcome in favour of full erasure would pit EU law against Christians because baptism testifies to the core of Christian identity.
Catholic law makes the same point. As translated by Zenit, a Church statement appealing to canon law said, “A minister cannot permit the celebration of other Sacraments if the reception of Baptism is not verified.”
About the Author: Rod Lampard
COMMENTARY / Fairness & Justice / Faith / Politics / World
SHARE >
We need your help. The continued existence of the Daily Declaration depends on the generosity of readers like you. Donate now. The Daily Declaration is committed to keeping our site free of advertising so we can stay independent and continue to stand for the truth.
Fake news and censorship make the work of the Canberra Declaration and our Christian news site the Daily Declaration more important than ever. Take a stand for family, faith, freedom, life, and truth. Support us as we shine a light in the darkness. Donate now.
Recent Articles:
Labor’s New Anti-Israel Sanctions Trigger Calls for Aussie Biscuit Boycott
20 November 2026
4 MINS
Israelis are calling for a boycott of Australian products following Labor’s latest sanctions against Israeli settlers, while reports suggest Israel may consider counter-sanctions.
Our Unhuman Past — and Future
20 November 2026
7.7 MINS
A revised edition of "Unhumans" examines the history, tactics and ideological foundations of communist revolutions, warning of socialism’s growing influence and its hostility to Christianity.
Hitler’s Legal Bid: Why Should Hamas Have All the Fun?
20 November 2026
2.1 MINS
A satirical legal battle exposes the absurdity of separating Hamas’s political and social activities from its military wing, using Hitler’s imagined defence to make the point.
How Snowy Hydro’s Costs Snowballed By Billions
20 November 2026
3 MINS
The Snowy Hydro scheme has ballooned from a $2 billion nation-building promise to a potential $42 billion financial disaster, exposing serious failures in planning, governance and accountability.
3 Ways for the Church to Fulfil Its Prophetic Duty to the Nation
20 November 2026
4.5 MINS
Christ’s authority extends over every sphere of society. The church must reclaim its prophetic voice and challenge ungodly civil governance.
Happy International Men’s Day, 19 November — ‘The Future is Everyone’
19 November 2026
2.7 MINS
International Men’s Day 2026 celebrates the contribution of men and boys, launches a landmark global report and calls for greater recognition, inclusion and equality.
Direct Democracy: Advocating for Australians to Be Involved in All Major Political Debates
19 November 2026
4.5 MINS
Amanda Flavell is campaigning for Swiss-style direct democracy in Australia, giving citizens greater power to challenge legislation and influence decisions on climate policy, censorship and women’s rights.
Use your voice today to protect
Faith · Family · Freedom · Life
MOST POPULAR
Samuel Hartwich
Rod Lampard
Rod Lampard
Rod Lampard
Dr Barry Manuel
William Kininmonth
Mark Powell
Dave Pellowe
Rod Lampard
Rod Lampard
ABOUT
The Daily Declaration is an Australian Christian news site dedicated to providing a voice for Christian values in the public square. Our vision is to see the revitalisation of our Judeo-Christian values for the common good. We are non-profit, independent, crowdfunded, and provide Christian news for a growing audience across Australia, Asia, and the South Pacific. The opinions of our contributors do not necessarily reflect the views of The Daily Declaration. Read More.
MOST COMMENTS
GOOD NEWS
Rod Lampard
Guest Writer
Rod Lampard
Rod Lampard
Rod Lampard
Kurt Mahlburg
Samuel Hartwich
Kurt Mahlburg
Samuel Hartwich
Rod Lampard
HALL OF FAME
Monica Bennett-Ryan
Cody Mitchell
Rachel Borneman
Rodney Rivers
Kurt Mahlburg
Kurt Mahlburg
Kurt Mahlburg
Kurt Mahlburg
Warwick Marsh
Kurt Mahlburg
BROWSE TOPICS
BROWSE GENRES