The Digital Duty of Care Is Still a Threat

The Digital Duty of Care Is Still a Threat

27 October 2026

25.2 MINS

Labor’s Digital Duty of Care Bill threatens free speech, empowers covert online surveillance, and imposes potentially burdensome regulations on Australian businesses.

The week before last, Labor introduced the Online Safety Amendment (Digital Duty of Care) Bill 2026 and, despite some minor amendments to the Exposure Draft, the Bill still poses an alarming threat to free speech in Australia.

Secret Accounts and Government Surveillance

First, the Bill allows for the Office of the eSafety Commissioner to create “sock puppet” accounts/identities, which presumably could be used to covertly “monitor” content on social media platforms, interact with other accounts, and generate material using AI.

Rather than merely observing social media, that office could run secret tests and conduct investigations.

Second, the concept of “serious harm” is still problematic and vague, and could be used as a cover-all term to force social media platforms to proactively restrict content that the government decides is “harmful”.

Any material or conduct that the Office of the eSafety Commissioner decides “may cause serious harm to children” must be restricted, and that could mean pretty much anything.

Moreover, the definition of “online service” in this Bill is so broad that it could capture over a million Australian businesses, triggering onerous obligations to abide by the Digital Duty of Care, including the requirement to produce annual online safety risk assessment reports in the same way billion-dollar platforms like X and Meta would have to. This is unfair and confusing, and has nothing to do with protecting children online. It is yet another utterly pointless and cumbersome imposition on small businesses.

Vague Definitions Threaten Free Speech

Just before the Bill was introduced, I sat down with US journalist and free speech advocate Michael Shellenberger in Parliament House to discuss the Exposure Draft. He considered it to be one of the most alarming pieces of proposed legislation concerning free speech he had ever seen.

You can watch that interview below.

Michael had much to say about the Bill, the state of free speech in the US and Australia respectively, and a range of issues, including the collapsing climate change narrative. It’s a refreshing discussion that you won’t want to miss.

Ultimately, this new version does not alleviate the concerns raised by the Exposure Draft. It is critical that we defeat this Bill.

YouTube Transcript: Michael Shellenberger – Digital Duty of Care

Senator Antic: Mike Shellenberger, thanks for dropping in. Thanks for coming back to Australia as well, by the way. It’s been a big flight, but it’s good to have you here on this fight. It’s a pretty important one, a pretty big one.

Michael Shellenberger: Thanks for having me. One of the best parts of Australia continuing to introduce censorship legislation is that we get to have a conversation, have a chat again.

Senator Antic: Yeah, I remember it wasn’t that long ago you were here, and we were downstairs.

Michael Shellenberger: Every couple of years.

Senator Antic: Yeah, every couple of years. A bit more than that. We’ve got a few of these clangers coming through legislatively. But last time around, we were here with the misinformation and disinformation bill, which you came and lent your voice to. Of course, that just disappeared. It didn’t make it to the Senate chamber at all. So it’s good, and thanks for taking the time.

Your background, we’ve talked about before on this BASED podcast—and you do get that tick of approval for the BASED podcast, we always say—really was in environmental activism from the left. You saw a different way, and you came around. But your work now has really revolved around Public, your media business, which, the way you describe it quite rightly, is filling the gap, filling the void between what the media are not telling you, back to what it used to be, which is a critical eye.

I don’t read anything. I really don’t. I think that’s ridiculous, but I’d be the least-read local-media politician in the country, for that exact reason. So I thought it’d be interesting to give us a bit of a background on Public and how it came to be, and how you’re now filling the void on some of these issues that are just not being picked up.

Michael Shellenberger: Yeah. The big event was the creation of this platform called Substack, which finally allowed journalists to receive subscription revenue directly rather than having to work for an outlet. So I just started to build a paying audience of subscribers that allow us to do investigations.

Then, in late 2022, a friend of mine who’s now the editor-in-chief of CBS News invited me into Twitter, where Elon Musk had just taken over and had opened up the files to everything. It was there that we discovered very partisan elements of the intelligence community had essentially been running a censorship and disinformation operation for several years. It really starts in 2016.

I’m also, I should say, CBR Chair of Politics, Censorship, and Free Speech at a new university in Austin called University of Austin.

It’s been a pleasure because one of the things that happened last time I was here—one of my favourite moments—is that we did a press conference, and one of the reporters asked, “Well, if you’re against the misinformation bill, then how are we going to fight misinformation?”

I said, “Isn’t that what you and I do as journalists all the time, is fight misinformation? If there weren’t misinformation out there, I wouldn’t have a job.”

So, for me, every time I see misinformation, I’m like, “Well, that’s a great story.”

Senator Antic: I remember that. I remember that vividly, actually. It was a really important point. It’s always this sort of line between the media in this country and hearing from people like yourself who have a different take on it, which is so refreshing.

You said on the website, actually—I wrote this down—“People don’t trust the news media, and it’s easy to see why. Major news media organisations reported inaccurately on Iraq, the weapons of mass destruction. They’ve dismissed as a debunked conspiracy theory the real possibility that COVID-19 could have escaped from a lab. And they’ve perpetuated misleading narratives around everything from rainforest destruction to biological sex to crime.”

That kind of sums it up, doesn’t it? It strikes me that that’s probably always been the case, but it’s really ramped up over the last 20 years, 30 years. It feels like the news media are about as captured as they could be. That’s true of the US. It’s true in Australia too.

So, are we getting through? Are we getting the message? Clearly, social media is making an impact, and Substacks like yours are making an impact. Otherwise, we wouldn’t be sitting here talking today.

Michael Shellenberger: Look at the political environment, how much it’s changed so dramatically. A right-wing populist is almost certainly going to be elected president of France next year. In Germany, the right-wing populist party is number one in the polls. A right-wing populist party here in Australia is number one in the polls.

The president of the United States is somebody who, essentially, they tried to put him in prison. They censored him. They de-platformed him from social media platforms. And I think it actually backfired.

I think there’s actually a consensus view. A New York Times journalist just came out with a big book that basically came to the same conclusion, which is that the left’s efforts to use illegitimate tactics to prevent Trump and the populist wing of the Republican Party from succeeding actually accrued to his benefit. Voters look at those illegal and unethical tactics, and they say, “Well, if we want to protect our rights, we actually need to support that candidate.”

So I’m not sure that Trump would have been able to be elected had they not attempted the persecution. I think that’s the silver lining on a lot of this stuff, including censorship: when you explain that something’s been censored, people want to pay more attention to it.

The Digital Duty of Care Bill

Senator Antic: Yeah, it does feel like that. It feels like around about the time of the FBI coming to his home and going through his wife’s drawers and his child’s—Barron’s—stuff, it felt like it had that Streisand effect, as they call it. There’s this sort of backlash against it. For political professionals, it always seems to me to be a pretty stupid thing to do, to try and take that line.

You’re here, of course, because of this Digital Duty of Care Bill. There’s an exposure draft. For people that don’t understand, that means the government put out—and some would say cynically—a document which is, “Well, this is what we’re proposing to bring to Parliament. We want to hear from you before we do.”

You’ve read it, and you’ve seen it. How bad is it?

Michael Shellenberger: Shockingly bad. I’ve never seen anything so extreme, so radical. It really allows the government to censor anything it wants. There’s four words: “may cause significant harm.” That’s all they need to say. Well, you could say that about anything, particularly when you’re talking about psychological harm—hurt feelings.

That was the first thing we drew attention to right away. But then we missed something that was buried deep in the bill. We only saw it after another reporter drew attention to it. Andrew Lowenthal and Michael Nayna actually wrote about this provision around what’s called sock puppets. They used to be called bots. These are basically fake social media accounts.

Two years ago, in the misinformation legislation, the Australian government wanted to crack down on these fake anonymous accounts. Now the government wants to use them essentially as informational warfare against the Australian people.

When people have tried to defend this provision of this law, they say, “Oh, that’s just to enforce the legislation.” But that’s not what the legislation says at all. It says very clearly it’s for educational, promotional purposes.

So the bill, as written, would allow the government to create an unlimited number of fake accounts, all of which would be disinformation, because they would be misrepresenting the accounts as though they belonged to ordinary Australians rather than being run out of the office of the eSafety Commissioner.

I have not seen this ever in legislation. Honestly, I’m still bothered by it because I can’t understand what they’re thinking. It’s so Orwellian. It’s so creepy. It’s so obviously unethical.

I don’t know why. Maybe they thought they could get away with it, and they almost did, because a lot of us missed it reading through that draft. But, for me, that’s just a new low for the censorship industrial complex.

Senator Antic: Yeah. Well, my worry about that is that if you put out a document, a bill that’s got a whole heap of things in there that you don’t necessarily want to get in your endgame, you’ve got something to trade with. Perhaps they’ll remove some of the worst parts of it, leaving us with something that’s still pretty bad. That’s happened a lot, of course, over the course of time.

So it may be that, but listening to you this morning talk to a group here in Parliament about the sock puppet phenomenon, it does feel a little bit as though, as you say, that could be used by the government to just seed a message.

If you’ve got an army of messages—and we’ve seen that. This very office, we found evidence during COVID that the department was using foreign contractors to flag posts during COVID for things we now know are true, like “masks don’t work” and whatever, flagging them, sending that off to Facebook and asking Facebook to remove them.

So we’ve already seen the government using this kind of intermediary approach. But in this, some would say that using a sock puppet is a way of watching the horizon, being out there looking online. You don’t see it that way. You see the possibility for this to be used as a vehicle for spreading the government agenda, effectively.

Michael Shellenberger: Yeah, absolutely. Look, it’s worth saying that there is absolutely a legitimate role for sock puppet fake accounts. If you’re investigating fraud or child predators, you’re not going to use your own—the police officer or the fraud investigator is not going to use their own account.

Senator Antic: Yeah.

Michael Shellenberger: They’re going to have to invent a fake account. But the legislation goes far beyond that. It says explicitly an unlimited number of accounts to disseminate information for promotional and educational purposes. So there’s really no other way to read that.

Maybe the strategy is they want to make it really extreme so they can remove that and suggest the bill’s been moderated. But so far, the responses from the government, as well as from ABC—an ABC reporter sort of defended this provision—have been to misrepresent what the legislation says. They’ve been suggesting that it is simply for enforcement, when the language, anyone can see for themselves, goes far beyond that.

Counter-Populist Tactics

Senator Antic: Would it be too cynical, do you think? We’ve seen, as you say, the rise of populist movements all over the world, and here in Australia too, particularly the right of politics. There is an interesting dynamic in politics everywhere. But would it be too cynical to suggest, do you think, that this is all a reflex towards the government protecting its own political patch by finding ways to shut it down? Or is that a conspiracy theory?

Michael Shellenberger: We can’t prove it, but that’s what it looks like. It looks like this is a counter-populist tactic to generate fake popular support for the government initiatives that they don’t genuinely have.

Within the first few days of this legislation being introduced, when you would go onto the normal mainstream news websites and look at the comments, it was 99 to 1, at best, against the legislation.

So the legislation’s unpopular, particularly with people that are the most online, which would be the people that are most affected by it. Obviously, there’s been a huge backlash in Australia on a set of issues that have been important to populists around the world: migration, trans, climate, issues where people are trying to divide us by race, and a real resistance to that.

So, yeah, it’s hard not to read this as an attempt to counter populism.

I’ll say one other thing, Senator, about this, which is that there is a history here to these—we used to call them bots. In 2017, the allegation was that the Russians had used bots to help elect President Trump. Without even questioning that the Russians did that, it was trivial. Hardly anybody saw them. There’s no evidence that it changed a single vote.

But the firm which wrote one of two reports for the Senate in 2017 on Russian interference in the 2016 elections, that organisation, New Knowledge, itself ran fake accounts, bots. In fact, they created them to make it look like Russians were supporting an Alabama Republican Senate candidate. They generated local news media coverage around this ostensible Russian support for the Republican candidate.

The firm then bragged about what they had done in a memo that was ultimately leaked to the New York Times. This is all a matter of public record now, that the organisation that was raising the alarm about Russian bots was itself running fake Russian bots. That’s one of the instances that’s important to understand.

The second is that there was an effort that was discovered through the Twitter Files by my colleague Matt Taibbi. Somebody had created a website, a dashboard called Hamilton 68. What that purported to show was that they had identified a large number of fake foreign accounts. But, in fact, when Matt looked into it, many of the accounts were authentic.

So it was a deception strategy. It was run by a former FBI agent, and they were trying to label authentic, genuine populist voices as inauthentic.

You see it working both directions. The Australian government is essentially proposing to create inauthentic, fake accounts to misrepresent them as authentic, and then we’ve seen similar groups of people in the past try to label authentic accounts as inauthentic.

The Global Censorship Network

Senator Antic: Yeah, it’s quite convoluted. When we spoke this morning, you spoke to a group here, and I asked you to explain as quickly as possible, because it’s a very complicated topic, this concept of how big this is globally, the censorship push.

You’ve talked about it a lot: the censorship industrial complex. I think you coined the phrase. We’ll give you credit for it anyway, because it’s an excellent one.

Senator Antic: The censorship industrial complex—it’s big. It’s involved. It looks to some of us who are looking at this from the outside as though, if you were a group of mobile elites across the world, you would use whatever mechanisms you could to shut down this debate, perhaps by shutting down free speech around the United States in other territories.

So Australia would be one of those. Europe, obviously, is getting a very similar play, all around the world. But is that too conspiratorial, in the sense that are we seeing the influence of intelligence, private equity? They call it the blob, of course. It’s been coined “the blob.” Can you break that down and explain it a bit?

Michael Shellenberger: Yeah. In truth, that part is not theoretical. We now have a significant amount of information, including many documents, showing that the censorship industrial complex is indeed a global phenomenon, that it works hand in glove—in fact, it’s arguably part of what we call the foreign policy establishment, or the blob—which consists of government-funded NGOs which act as intermediary organisations for the intelligence community. None of that is controversial.

We have, as recently as last year, the fall of 2025, a private, off-the-record meeting at Stanford University, which is one of the key hubs for the censorship industrial complex, meeting with platform censors from Brazil, the European Union, the UK, New Zealand, Australia, Canada, as well as the Americans who were now out of power because the Trump administration has shut down significant parts of that.

One of the participants in that meeting was so concerned about it that they leaked their programme to a member of Congress, who then gave it to us, and we covered it.

Additionally, in February of this year, the House Judiciary Committee of the United States issued a report showing that, in fact, our worst fears, which were that the European governments were going to try to censor us Americans, had already been occurring. The European Union had been meeting with social media platforms and actively changing the so-called terms of service, the rules that we all have to follow in using those social media platforms.

Also completely unknown, there was one exchange where TikTok executives asked the Europeans, “When you say you want to discuss election misinformation, do you just mean in Europe, or do you mean in the United States as well?” And they said, “In the United States as well.”

So this has all been really well documented at this point. There are an alarming number of people that were in the intelligence community that went to work for social media platforms, others who went to work for nonprofit organisations that served as conduits or intermediaries for the Department of Homeland Security.

Meanwhile, in Europe, their censorship system is in place, and it operates exactly the same as what they were trying to do in the United States, where government-funded and government-authorised NGOs make censorship demands of the social media platforms, as they call it, “trusted flaggers.”

So it’s essentially censorship by proxy. That’s the model that they’re all aiming for. But, honestly, nobody does it quite like Australia, and the proposal here is much more aggressive and extreme.

Senator Antic: Yeah, it does feel like that. It feels like it’s really gone up a notch. The sock puppet stuff is one of them, but it’s this relentless push towards it.

I’ve been saying to people, for what is a very important issue, the main issue of the day here in Australia is inflation, cost of living, migration in some circles as well. So there’s a whole heap of them, but this one keeps coming to the floor of Parliament, right? It seems to be out of step.

Impact on US-Australia Relations

Senator Antic: What is the problem they’re trying to fix, I guess, is the issue. They would say safety, online safety, kids and whatever. But on the hierarchy of needs, that must be somewhere right down the bottom, so it does stand out a little bit.

But from the point of view of what’s happening in the United States, there has been a statement, I think, from the ambassador, the United States ambassador, saying, “We would look very dimly upon efforts to clamp down on free speech.”

Does this have a realistic possibility, do you think, of damaging the relationship between the two countries, or will it just blast away and disappear off into the sunset? And do you think the Trump administration, with people like Jim Jordan who’ve been doing such good work in this area, do you think there’s any possibility of blowback towards Aussies?

Michael Shellenberger: I think so. And I think there would have been a lot more if the president and the Republicans weren’t in the middle of really important midterm elections. They’ve been heavily focused on that. I was actually surprised they made any response, given that they’re in the midst of these midterms.

So, no, I think it’s a huge problem. Your Prime Minister Albanese, of course, was very proud of the trade and minerals agreement that he struck with President Trump. But I think we’ve seen an administration that has been willing to put its money where its mouth is when it comes to free speech.

There’s obviously limitations there. There’s obviously other considerations. We want to keep prices low as well, so we don’t necessarily want to have big trade conflicts. But you have to remember, President Trump was kicked off the major social media platforms.

One of the discoveries that I made when I did the Twitter Files was that Twitter kicked President Trump off their social media platform in violation of Twitter’s own terms of service. In other words, they’ve tried to make the terms of service as restrictive as possible, but when they don’t get what they want through the terms of service, they just break the terms of service.

So you have a president here that acutely feels the censorship as an injustice, and you have other members of the administration, including Bobby Kennedy, who were censored quite badly.

As somebody that’s also been censored, I can tell you that it’s a feeling—you feel quite insulted and quite humiliated. That anger doesn’t dissipate easily. I think that’s why so many—and you see it online—people are very incensed about the idea that some bureaucrat is going to be able to decide what we can see and say online.

So more could be coming, I would say, after the elections, from the White House and the president.

Senator Antic: There’s still a live issue around how it is that we’ve got this world now where there’s this dying legacy media, which always were privately owned anyway. So there were always editorial positions there. But we now have this world where there are effectively three or four major tech companies that decide what you can see and what you can’t.

They’ve traded on this premise that it’s free speech and whatever. Certainly, X has done that more than most in recent times. But it still leaves us with this problem, doesn’t it, that ultimately, if another COVID were to come along—and it does feel like censorship online has, I know there’d be others that would argue with me, but it feels like it’s retreated a little bit from the heady days of people getting pulled down for saying “masks don’t work.”

That is still a big issue, though, when it comes to how to protect free speech online. No one’s really cracked that yet because, ultimately, these are companies that can do their own thing, their own private equity, shareholding and whatever. I don’t know how we fix that in itself.

It feels like we’re still grappling with how to deal with this very dynamic space online.

Solutions for Free Speech

Senator Antic: Do you see any solutions to that so that we do get true free speech online, or is it just going to be reliant on someone purchasing it, like Elon, that’s got a bit of an idea about free speech?

Michael Shellenberger: Yeah, the short answer is the latter. Really, free speech, honestly, globally, is being propped up by a single person, Elon Musk.

Now, Mark Zuckerberg, in January 2025, essentially joined Elon in rejecting the censorship approach of having little specialised committees of bureaucrats that nobody knew to decide what was true and false, moving to more of what they call a Community Notes crowdsourcing approach to fact-checking, which I think has been much better.

The best solution, in my view, would be to allow all adult users to decide on the filters of all legal content. Illegal content is illegal content. Nobody questions that that should be censored, but all adult users should be able to decide their own content on social media platforms.

I’ve written up a white paper for that policy proposal. It hasn’t exactly gone viral as an idea, I think in part because at least the political right has felt like, under Elon, they finally had a platform where they can freely speak to each other.

It’s important to remember the closure of the internet, essentially from 2016 to around 2023, that prevented the political right from even having a conversation with itself. So now that X has been essentially liberated, and you have free speech travelling online, I think the pressure for some totally different system has died down.

Senator Antic: Yeah.

Michael Shellenberger: But we are definitely not out of the woods. I was feeling much more confident until the Australian legislation was introduced.

Simultaneously, the British government has introduced censorship legislation that’s being championed by the prime minister and Andy Burnham as one of his first major priorities in coming in as prime minister.

You had asked earlier what’s motivating it. I just think that the establishment’s agenda is now deeply unpopular. It’s unpopular on migration, on energy, on race. Dividing us by race—people don’t want that. Making people agree that somehow people can change their biological sex, which no real scientist thinks is possible.

The public doesn’t like that, and they are revolting politically, and that’s why we’re seeing a wave of populist success around the world. Rather than rethink its agenda, the liberal establishment is demanding censorship.

The Role of USAID

Senator Antic: Yeah, it makes a lot of sense. I think that’s my summary and take of it as well.

We have seen—obviously, the NGO space has been very important to this. It’s been, I think, more persuasive than people in Australia probably understand because it’s generally come out of America and the US aid programme.

But the Trump administration pulled the plug on USAID, to much outcry on the left in the US, because it does sound like US aid, but, of course, it’s much more than—well, it’s actually not that at all in many respects. It’s just the establishment’s funding of these sorts of things.

Has that made a difference to the censorship industrial complex? That would have all happened, I think, since you were last here. I think probably before the election, just after, probably two years ago. So has it made a difference to the whole landscape, or is it unchanged in this area?

Michael Shellenberger: I think it’s huge. I think there were much bigger ambitions to cut the size of government, some of which was done, and the number of federal employees in the United States has significantly declined since Trump came to power.

But the USAID story, as far as I understand it—and I’ve heard no information contradicting that—

Senator Antic: Can you just explain that, by the way, first of all? Just what USAID is, for people that are listening that don’t quite get it.

Michael Shellenberger: Yeah. Essentially, the United States Agency for International Development was created in the early ’60s by President Kennedy as essentially another, a civilian wing of the intelligence community, to involve itself in the advance of what we call soft power, but also engaged in regime change operations or regime stabilisation operations.

To give you a sense of it, one of the grantees of USAID was receiving $500 million a year just to support so-called journalism around the world. So it was a huge propaganda arm.

I think people often forget that because we think of the CIA, and you think of an organisation that’s involved with special forces and dropping commandos into countries and doing kinetic action. But the CIA has always been a political organisation aimed at trying to influence elections around the world, which is why, when CIA intermediaries talk about foreign interference, they know exactly what they’re talking about.

But USAID’s effect was mostly global. What I thought was so fascinating about it is that it appears as though what happened is that President Trump had authorised Elon Musk to go and essentially audit all these various federal agencies, and the USAID people had refused to allow Elon Musk and his people to actually look under the hood. So they just shut it down.

I think that was the right approach. You can’t have rogue federal agencies that are accountable to no one, not even the president of the United States. They have to be shut down. So the death penalty came for USAID, I think justified, because they wanted to operate as a completely rogue agency.

There’s been a bunch of claims online about the effect of USAID going away and the rise of the success of right-wing populists. It’s probably a bit overstated, but there’s certainly some truth to it that, without USAID, there haven’t been all these left-wing NGOs that have been demanding the censorship that we had before. It was certainly a key hub for the censorship industrial complex.

President Trump also shut down a whole track of the National Science Foundation, which is our biggest funder of academic research, that was funding a lot of censorship tools that they were creating and then giving away to social media platforms.

Senator Antic: Right.

Michael Shellenberger: Then, of course, they shut down the Department of Homeland Security’s censorship operation. All those things have had a huge effect.

We’ve seen some of those censorship people then go into academia. Some of them have gone to Europe. But you look at Australia, you look at Britain, you look at the European Union still doing it. We just see clearly the coordination is continuing.

We had hoped it had finally gone away and been discredited. My hope is that what we’re seeing in Australia is a kind of last, desperate rearguard action. But we’ll see. If the legislation passes, then you guys are in for several more years of having to deal with this.

Intel Community Influence

Senator Antic: As a longtime scholar of mid-’90s gangster rap music—which may shock you to hear, but my early years were replete with NWA and the whole lot—I was intrigued to hear a take on some of the USAID funding and the correlation with rap music. I loved that because I’d never, ever taken rap music as being a CIA sting operation or something like that.

But it’s a fascinating history of funding and what’s come of it. I think people would be shocked to learn where these avenues go, and how far and wide it’s gone. It’s potentially even, I think, probably had an influence here as well.

It’s often been said to me that these buildings, these legislatures, are full of intel community people in offices behind doors in here. Do you get that feeling from Australian federal Parliament? Would it be possible, do you think, that these buildings could just have agency plants in here?

Michael Shellenberger: Oh, sure. Look, we know that the CIA funded journalists for a long time, had control over journalists. We have people that were in the CIA that are now elected to Congress. They’re sort of open about it. It’s not secretive.

So, yeah, certainly I see people, and the online expression is they seem “glowy.” You’ll look at their LinkedIn page, and it will be something like, went to college and went to school in Georgetown, learned Russian and Arabic, and then they went to work for some national security think tank. You’re kind of like, “Okay, got it. Looks like it.”

So, yeah. I think part of the lesson is just that free speech is such a sacred right, and that there’s a lot of noise, but when we can get people focused on protecting this fundamental freedom, I do think it rises above all of the creeping around and all of the skulduggery.

Because the truth of the matter is that there were a lot of bad actors in the intelligence community, but there’s actually a lot of really good people too that wanted free speech. A lot of our sources would be from within the intelligence community, and 100% of them were people that were sharing information because they really supported what we were doing in terms of exposing censorship.

So when we look back at the last 10 years, I think the way I would describe it is—I wouldn’t want to say that the intelligence community did these things. I would say it was ideological and partisan actors abusing their power as intelligence agents or as intermediaries to intelligence.

Climate Change and Optimism

Senator Antic: That’s a really helpful observation, actually. I think it’s a very timely one. It applies everywhere. Applies to politicians as well, of course. There are some good and some bad.

I just want to quickly touch on this because we’re running out of time a little bit. You’re a busy man. You’re doing some important meetings here, which is great, but to the issue of the climate change agenda.

Now, this is a completely different lane, but last time we spoke a little bit about this. Pardon the pun, but it feels like the steam’s coming off this a little bit because of the fact that it’s largely made up, number one, and number two, because of the introduction of AI data centres and now the need for power.

Senator Antic: There’s been some interesting observations out of the UN, I think, about how things that were supposed to happen didn’t happen. What a great shock, in terms of cities being underwater and so forth. We’ve just been round and round the mulberry bush on this for 20 years, so we’re all getting a bit tired of it.

You’ve been right down in the front lines of this one. I’m just interested to hear your take on where that’s up to. If it is the case that the heat is coming out of it—once again, terrible pun—then what’s caused it? Is it AI? Is it that shift towards the need for energy?

Michael Shellenberger: It’s such a good question. I don’t think there’s any doubt that—Trump has basically dismantled all of our major climate policies, pulled us out of the United Nations treaties. There was no protest.

Where was—Greta Thunberg was off doing stuff in Gaza, but all of the giants of the climate movement were really quiet. I think they were demoralised, defeated.

To your point, one of the big things that people had said is that all the coral on the Great Barrier Reef was going to die, and now we’re at record coral on the Great Barrier Reef. By the way, one of the first years when they recorded record coral, the activists got Facebook to censor that information. It had to happen a few years in a row for Facebook finally to allow it to travel.

But basically, the big impacts, we just haven’t seen them. We’re not seeing this huge acceleration of sea-level rise. Arctic ice hasn’t declined for 20 years, between 2005 and 2020—sorry, 2005 and 2024.

Droughts—I just did a whole series of articles on droughts and hurricanes, and essentially we’re not seeing the increases that they had claimed to see. Of course, we’re becoming much less vulnerable to natural disasters. Nobody should ever die from a cyclone or a hurricane. There’s no need. We actually didn’t have any hurricanes. We had a record lack of hurricanes in the United States. So I just think the science hasn’t delivered on it.

I think it’s important to remember that this apocalyptic approach to issues first was around nuclear in general, which they had a better case for because nuclear weapons truly would cause havoc. After the Cold War, where the threat of nuclear war went down, then the left really picked up on climate change.

Now I think that’s faded, and I think it’s pretty clear that the apocalyptic vision is now going to be attached to AI. In fact, you look at the marches, and I’m like, “Well, those are the exact same people that were…” So I think that’s a big part of it.

But, look, I think the story that still hasn’t been told is that basically every environmental trend is going in the right direction. We’re experiencing wonderful global greening thanks to the higher carbon dioxide in the atmosphere.

We used to call it the greenhouse effect, and you forgot that we have greenhouses because they’re really good for growing plants. But essentially, we’re growing so much more food on the same amount of land that the pressure on the natural environment just isn’t what it was even 50 years ago.

I’ve written a book on homelessness, and I’ve written a book on the environment, and the environmental book is actually the most positive, optimistic book because of the trends. People should enjoy our beautiful natural environment. The world is definitely not coming to an end. It’s not getting worse from an environmental perspective.

But the sad part is, I think most people still don’t realise that. There’s a huge percentage of people that think the end is nigh. But the truth of the matter is that we’ve had a very good outcome. We’ve just been continuing to decarbonise, and people are moving to cleaner sources of energy. So it’s mostly just a story of good news, which I think to some people is bad news.

Senator Antic: Bad news. Yeah, that’s right. Well, the good news is that the environment’s going well. Bad news is the polar bear behind you. It’s just come down because there’s so many of them now. There’s polar bears everywhere.

But, look, we’re going on. Thanks so much for dropping in. Thanks for coming to Australia as well. Hopefully, if we can knock this one off, you can have a bit of a holiday somewhere else sometime and not have to come down to Australia and teach us the woes of censorship and the censorship industrial complex, because we’re slow learning at the moment.

But thanks very much, and good to catch up.

Michael Shellenberger: Yeah, you too, Senator. Godspeed in defeating the bill.

Senator Antic: Yeah, thanks, Mike. Good on you.

___

Republished with thanks to Senator Alex Antic. Image courtesy of Adobe.

We need your help. The continued existence of the Daily Declaration depends on the generosity of readers like you. Donate now. The Daily Declaration is committed to keeping our site free of advertising so we can stay independent and continue to stand for the truth.

Fake news and censorship make the work of the Canberra Declaration and our Christian news site the Daily Declaration more important than ever. Take a stand for family, faith, freedom, life, and truth. Support us as we shine a light in the darkness. Donate now.

7 Comments

  1. e8bb2e62d2c730e997dece78954b123bc9765acb72ef0bf9d6c1df64bf9b6810?s=54&d=mm&r=g
    James 27 October 2026 at 8:54 am - Reply

    What’s the betting that the e-safety commissioner will use her powers to silence Family First and One Nation and a few other parties that are a possible threat to the Uniparty.

  2. 512e9ce03dddd351694be567063f2e2704b64f97f78424260660e23d79e226b0?s=54&d=mm&r=g
    Maureen Lange 27 October 2026 at 9:44 am - Reply

    I wish all this nonsense would stop. We do not need babysitting, we are adults and should be making our own decisions in life, we will all end up like those in the “Time Machine”( H.G.Wells I think)., where everyone wanders around mindless with nothing to do but eat, sleep and play. Really????????????

  3. Kym Farnik
    Kym Farnik 27 October 2026 at 10:23 am - Reply

    Thanks Alex. This bill is absolutely insidious.

    My Mother-in-Law and Dad both lived through Nazi (socialist) Germany under Hitler.
    Dad turned 18 in 1932. He did not talk about it a lot, but the suppression of dissent, burning books, and removal of freedom in general were huge issues to Dad.

    The occasions we did discuss it, when I was older, showed me how intrinsically important freedom, especially freedom of speech/expression is.
    Property take over was a big part of the Nazi agenda. Jews and others lost their homes and businesses. It was evil.
    One of the justifications for book burning (which started in 1933, long before the war) was the idea of preventing subversion of the Nazi ideals.

    The books targeted for burning were those viewed as being subversive or as representing ideologies opposed to Nazism. These included books written by Jewish, communist, socialist, anarchist, liberal, pacifist, and sexologist authors among others. This included porn and other genuinely bad things, which was part of the justification.

    How did it happen…
    People wanted ‘safety’ and ‘security’ at any cost which ended up being death. Hitler promised (and only partly delivered), jobs, hospitals, VW cars, and a promise of Lebensraum i.e. living room, hence invasion of neighbouring nations leading to WWII.

    Most people gave up their freedoms with no understanding of the consequences.
    Some recent laws here in Australia like social media bans, and Calvary Hospital take-over are Hilter-esque !
    This new Digital Safety Bill is pure evil.
    It is akin to the Nazi Enabling Act.

    Big call you say?
    Most have no idea what really happened when the national socialists (Nazis) got power !!!

    This is the same as the Antifa Marxist Left labor/teals/greens agenda today.
    Do not think it is not the same, Hitler started soft then took absolute power and all dissent and freedom was shut down.

  4. f910f8648b50864a0a4fa9cff6838335a9df65757870ba46526d3fd0fd4d5768?s=54&d=mm&r=g
    Ian Moncrieff 27 October 2026 at 11:34 am - Reply

    Be encouraged Senator Antic. We are praying for you and your stand for freedom of speech.

  5. 02ca193efed524ee52d102099f5e1c7361d30c232a847719d07e3bd0beac701c?s=54&d=mm&r=g
    Courtney Castle 27 October 2026 at 1:35 pm - Reply

    You are absolutely correct in your commentary, Kym. God is all over this like ‘white on rice’! Never fear as Jesus is coming to fix their little red wagons if they continue on this path. We need to pray, praise & worship through these times. My slightly humorous comments are just to make light of a very serious matter only because we followers of Jesus already know the end of this world’s story. ✝️

  6. 0420391077f8111996bb838f71e47c0f9bd9c371f65b3429541324068047dbf1?s=54&d=mm&r=g
    countess antonia scrivanich 27 October 2026 at 2:09 pm - Reply

    Evil Bill to stop any of the Truth from becoming national knowledge. Meanwhile our country ( our ideals, culture and religion ) are being destroyed by our government’s policies and the Third World it has imported who live off Welfare and by robbing a business when the rubbish is taken out. The same ethnic are offering “free ” bracelets to tourists at the Colosseum , Trevi fountain, etc in Rome where they take large rocks to throw at tourists who photograph them. Ditto in Florence, Venice, Naples. Europe, also, has organised groups of Romana pickpockets. Australia , too, is lost with these imported “workers “.

  7. Stephen Lewin
    Stephen Lewin 28 October 2026 at 3:52 pm - Reply

    Thanls Senator Antic for your ongiong stand for freedom of speech and ID chsllenges

Leave A Comment

Recent Articles:

Use your voice today to protect

Faith · Family · Freedom · Life

MOST POPULAR

ABOUT

The Daily Declaration is an Australian Christian news site dedicated to providing a voice for Christian values in the public square. Our vision is to see the revitalisation of our Judeo-Christian values for the common good. We are non-profit, independent, crowdfunded, and provide Christian news for a growing audience across Australia, Asia, and the South Pacific. The opinions of our contributors do not necessarily reflect the views of The Daily Declaration. Read More.

MOST COMMENTS

GOOD NEWS

HALL OF FAME

BROWSE TOPICS

BROWSE GENRES