
Never Trust a Liar With Your Algorithm
With Germany drafting rules to mandate State-approved news in social media feeds, Australians might reasonably wonder what comes next.
Let me ask you a question.
If you discovered your accountant had a serious gambling problem, would you let him keep doing your books?
Or would you say,
‘Listen, Shifty McLedger, I don’t think you should be running my finances anymore.’
If you discovered the chef at your local café had numerous criminal convictions for poisoning people, would you keep eating his food?
Or would you say,
‘I’m sorry, Gordon Ramslay, but I’m no longer comfortable with you cooking my meals.’
And what about this:
If you discovered your Prime Minister was a compulsive liar — about everything from falling off a stage to compiling a dirt file — would you let him anywhere near your social media feed?
Or would you say,
‘Hey, Albanocio, if I can’t trust you to tell the truth about anything, I’m definitely not going to trust you to decide what I can and see online.’
And I know, I know… the Prime Minister’s pinkie-swearing that’s not what he’s up to, but you see the problem, right? We just don’t believe him.
And that’s not on us. That’s on him!
When Governments Want a Say in Your Feed
A lot of people have talked about the Digital Duty of Care Bill, and a lot of people have talked about Anthony Albanese’s rather elastic relationship with the truth.
But not enough people have considered those two things in tandem.
Imagine a Prime Minister who can’t stop misleading the public, suddenly discovering he could mislead the public on an industrial scale if only he controlled what the public sees.
A politician who can’t reliably be trusted to describe reality suddenly gets a say in which bits of reality you’re allowed to encounter.
It’s like appointing a convicted arsonist to decide which buildings need smoke alarms.
But how would he convince the public to hand over control of their online experience?
Well, you’re all very familiar with the story.
It started with a social media ban for under-16s… to protect the children.
And — I’m using the PM’s own words here — “the inevitable next stage” was doing something about the ‘algorithm’… that annoying feature that spontaneously causes people to see right-wing material, or — if you prefer — the way the world really is.
The PM told us that forcing big tech to let us opt out of the algorithm feature wasn’t about control; it was about giving people choice.
And this time, they’re telling the truth.
Seriously.
This time, they really, truly, cross our black hearts and hope to be re-elected are telling the God they don’t believe in’s honest truth.
Sure, they didn’t tell the truth about power prices.
Or stage 3 tax cuts.
Or negative gearing.
Or capital gains tax.
Or falling off the stage.
Or joking about the Japanese PM’s melons.
Or the Helen Haines dirt file.
But this time we can believe them.
So what’s the next stage?
Germany’s 20 Per Cent Rule for Approved News
Well, you might be interested to know that the German Government has just released a draft of its latest version of their Digital Duty of Care bill.
And get this… the draft mandates that 20 percent of the algorithm has to include government-approved news services.
Well, colour me astonished.
Who could possibly have predicted that a government determined to protect us from dangerous online content might eventually decide it should have a hand in choosing the content we see?
Germany’s Digital Media Interstate Treaty, released on September 28 and open for consultation until November 13, mandates that every fifth social media post citizens see should come from a pool of news outlets recognised for providing what regulators consider to be diversity.
The legislation is being sold as a way of saving the public from what officials call… “algorithmic displacement”.
Which I think means… displacement from the comfortable, government-approved version of reality.
Under the German proposal, regulators would determine which outlets qualify for preferential visibility on your social media feed.
Why 20 percent? Well, I suppose 100 percent would sound suspicious.
Diversity of Sources Doesn’t Mean Diversity of Views
The German Government says it will ensure that people are getting a diverse number of news sites in their news feed.
And that’s the first of many problems with this draft legislation. A diversity of news sources doesn’t mean a diversity of views.
If you’re getting the ABC, SBS, CNN and the BBC, are you getting a diversity of views? Or are you getting a diversity of news sites all promoting the same worldview?
The German system gives regulators the power to determine which outlets qualify for preferential treatment.
But official recognition isn’t the same thing as accuracy. Established media can be wrong. Public broadcasters can be wrong. Governments can be spectacularly wrong.
The problem isn’t that every approved outlet is untrustworthy. The problem is that the state is being asked to distinguish the voices that deserve preferential visibility from those that don’t.
Now, why would they want to do that?
Which brings us back to Anthony Albanese. With his love of… how can I be kind… reframing reality… do you not think the German laws would appeal here?
The German legislation is still in draft form.
It is not yet a law, and we shouldn’t pretend that Australia has proposed an identical 20 per cent quota.
But it would be astonishingly naïve to assume the broader idea has nothing to do with the direction of travel here.
From Online Safety to Government-Controlled Information
Albanese has, for a long time, been invoking the language of safety, choice and protection.
And he’s already demonstrated a willingness to use government power to reshape what Australians can do online.
So when he tells us he has no intention of controlling what we see online, perhaps we should remember his record.
This is a Prime Minister who asks us to believe remarkable things about his government’s performance.
And when questions are raised about his own conduct, we’ve been treated to explanations that defy gravity.
The German proposal provides a glimpse of where the logic of these schemes can lead.
First, the government tells you that some content is dangerous.
Then it tells you that algorithms are making the problem worse.
Then it tells you that platforms must give you more choice.
And eventually, someone decides that the best way to guarantee a diversity of views is to mandate which views must appear.
At which point, the government has helpfully solved the problem of online diversity by deciding what diversity looks like.
And if you object, well, perhaps your objection is precisely the sort of content that needs a little less visibility.
That’s the danger.
Slippery Slope
I’m not one of those who believes that every government begins with a master plan to censor its critics.
But we should all be able to see how every new power is introduced as a modest, reasonable response to a problem — and then becomes the foundation for the next power.
The guardrails move. The definitions expand. The exceptions multiply.
And the thing that was unthinkable yesterday becomes the sensible compromise of tomorrow.
We should judge this government not merely by what it says it intends to do, but by what it’s already done, the powers it’s seeking and the incentives those powers create.
And when a government with a decidedly patchy record of telling the truth asks us to trust it with greater control over the information we receive, well, scepticism is not paranoia.
It is basic civic hygiene.
In fact, the more emphatically this government insists it would never go there, the more carefully we should examine the road signs.
Because if there is one thing this government has demonstrated a considerable talent for, it is saying one thing and doing another.
___
Republished with thanks to The James Macpherson Report. Image courtesy of Adobe.
5 Comments
Leave A Comment
Recent Articles:
18 November 2026
4 MINS
Halloween and funeral plans may help us confront the practicalities of death, but neither addresses the most important question: where will we spend eternity?
18 November 2026
2.9 MINS
Australia’s proposed digital duty of care bill aims to protect children online, but Catholic and Anglican bishops warn its vague provisions could threaten religious freedom and free speech on the internet.
18 November 2026
3.3 MINS
Britain’s proposed conversion therapy laws could criminalise parents, restrict Christian counsel and silence dissent, while a taxpayer-funded helpline’s actual call numbers fall dramatically short of claims.
17 November 2026
2.8 MINS
Australian singer-songwriter Jonathan Bone is breaking new ground with a bold pro-life anthem, created alongside his teenage son, celebrating the dignity and value of unborn life.
17 November 2026
2 MINS
Australia’s AUKUS submarine deal faces another bizarre objection, with senior Navy officials warning that American military policies could exclude transgender and non-binary Australian personnel.
17 November 2026
4.6 MINS
As occult practices gain popularity, are churches equipped to confront spiritual darkness? Dr Barry Manuel urges Christians to recognise spiritual warfare and prepare for deliverance ministry.
17 November 2026
1.6 MINS
NSW Labor has devoted 31 pages of legislation to removing the pronouns "he" and "she" from state laws, raising fresh questions about its priorities and understanding of biological sex.






This summary of the Prime Minister’s inability to speak truthful statements is a great concern to all in Australia.
One of the greatests concerns is emphasized by you James – “Albanese has, for a long time, been invoking the language of safety, choice and protection. And he’s already demonstrated a willingness to use government power to reshape what Australians can do online. So when he tells us he has no intention of controlling what we see online, perhaps we should remember his record.”…We can’t afford to put trust in a leader who is not intending to carry out the best protection methods for children and who may want to use the situation for other reasons and thus manipulate surveillance laws.
We have reached the stage where we need a lie detector test…The same machine has been used to determine truth for many years where the truth needs to be known and any fabrications be exposed. Otherwise we remain a nation in peril.
Wasn’t it Ronald Reagan who said, ‘The nine most terrifying words in the English language are: I’m from the Government, and I’m here to help.’
Mr Albanese’s declarations seem, now, to make that an understatement.
When is a con not a con? Ask Albo?
The USA will never give up their guns. We and the Brits are now “sitting ducks” for an eventual violent Takeover of our countries to be replaced/ruled by those responsible for the biggest enslavement of innocent people throughout history which continues today, which no one will mention. The numbers of slaves in both South and North America are peanuts in comparison with the millions enslaved in North Africa, ME, Caucasus, Spain, the Balkans, India, SE Asia over the centuries—which still continues in Africa today ( Nigeria, Sudan, etc ) . Thomas Jefferson,the author of the American Constitution, was disappointed with Federalism which he said was worse than the king they had replaced because the USA government had gained too much power over the States, instituted a bloated bureaucracy, and created a huge debt. To me it sounds just like what Australia has become , and where no State can block the importation of people whose aim is to kill and enslave us. This new Act of parliament is to prevent us seeing and reading the truth on You Tube, etc about what is going on in the World, to prosecute anyone who reveals the Truth. Will Pauline Hanson and One Nation be jailed and/or prosecuted if too popular ?
My Mother-in-Law and Dad both lived through Nazi (socialist) Germany under Hitler.
Dad turned 18 in 1932. He did not talk about it a lot, but the suppression of dissent, burning books, and removal of freedom in general were huge issues to Dad.
The occasions we did discuss it, when I was older, showed me how intrinsically important freedom, especially freedom of speech/expression is.
Property take over was a big part of the Nazi agenda. Jews and others lost their homes and businesses. It was evil.
One of the justifications for book burning (which started in 1933, long before the war) was the idea of preventing subversion of the Nazi ideals.
The books targeted for burning were those viewed as being subversive or as representing ideologies opposed to Nazism. These included books written by Jewish, communist, socialist, anarchist, liberal, pacifist, and sexologist authors among others. This included porn and other genuinely bad things, which was part of the justification.
How did it happen…
People wanted ‘safety’ and ‘security’ at any cost which ended up being death. Hitler promised (and only partly delivered), jobs, hospitals, VW cars, and a promise of Lebensraum i.e. living room, hence invasion of neighbouring nations leading to WWII.
Most people gave up their freedoms with no understanding of the consequences.
Some recent laws here in Australia like social media bans, and Calvary Hospital take-over are Hilter-esque !
This new Digital Safety Bill is pure evil.
It is akin to the Nazi Enabling Act.
Big call you say?
Most have no idea what really happened when the national socialists (Nazis) got power !!!
This is the same as the Antifa Marxist Left labor/teals/greens agenda today.
Do not think it is not the same, Hitler started soft then took absolute power and all dissent and freedom was shut down.